News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:"Are you the one?" is free money by hatthew on Monday December 15, 2025 @07:17PM (#46282973)
Yes, you learn more than 1 bit in that case. However, if you are told A is false, you still don't know whether B or C is true, so you gain less than 1 bit. Assuming A, B and C all have equal probability, your average/expected information gain is <1 bit.

If you ask the question "which of A, B, or C is true?" then you're not asking a yes/no question, and it's not surprising that you expect to gain more than 1 bit of information.

Re:"Are you the one?" is free money by jncfhnb on Tuesday December 16, 2025 @08:43AM (#46288383)
but that’s all consistent. “Expected” gain is less than 1 for the truth booths and sometimes > 1 for actuals; and is > 1 on expected value of the match ups, which aren’t binary questions.
Re:"Are you the one?" is free money by hatthew on Wednesday December 17, 2025 @12:28AM (#46298606)
Sure, and the issue is that the article says "Suppose we have calculated the expected information gained by potential truth booths like below:" and then lists some values >1

edit: just saw that the article fixed this recently, and the values are now <1