Re:SpaceX's First Official Cargo Resupply Mission to the ISS...
by nkoren on Monday October 08, 2012 @07:25AM
(#4626338)
All very true. Although as I note in a thread below, I'm starting to wonder whether this was truly an explosion (ie of the combustion chamber and everything), or simply a nozzle collapse following a commanded shutdown of the engine. The latter would be relatively benign, aside from some aerodynamic effects which the flight dynamics software obviously handled without trouble.
And you're right -- for reusability, they do need to get their per-engine reliability above 98%. That would produce a mission reliability of 97.1% (assuming that 2 engines out causes a loss of vehicle, which I understand is only the case during the earlier phases of flight). At 99% engine reliability, you get 99.3% per-flight reliability -- which strikes me as the point where reusability starts to become very sensible. I have considerable confidence that SpaceX will be able to do this.
This has been done many times in history, in Saturn V and Space Shuttle for example.
But in this case, since the engines are so small, it seems the explosion tactic paid off very well.
Hopefully they can test Merlin-1D adequately. If you aim for reusability, your reliability must go up considerably. If you plan to fly something for 100 times, you probably can not tolerate 98% per-flight reliability. A lot depends on assumptions of course.