News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Tor Project is switching to Rust by twhb on Friday December 12, 2025 @12:31PM (#46246384)
This tool is deeply flawed. Fingerprinting protection is sometimes done by binning, which this tool rewards, and is sometimes done by randomizing, which this tool harshly punishes. The net result is it generally guides you away from the strongest protection.

The flip side of this, having the complementary flaw of testing only persistence, not uniqueness, is (warning, real tracking link) fingerprinting.com/demo. You can try resetting your ID and seeing if it changes here. Since tracking requires (a degree of) uniqueness AND (a degree of) persistence, the danger signal is only failing both the EFF test and this test.

Failing both is a requirement to derive meaning, not being lax: measuring only uniqueness would fail a random number generator, and measuring only persistence would fail the number 4.

Re:The Tor Project is switching to Rust by ekjhgkejhgk on Friday December 12, 2025 @01:33PM (#46247138)
You make an interesting point on binning vs randomization. I'm not an expert but to me your point is consistent with Tor having the "best protection" according to the website, because I know that Tor's strategy is binning. However, this is what actually makes sense for many variables though. For example, font sizes come in integers. If you're trying to be clever by "randomizing" and claiming to use decimal-sized, you might be the only person in the world to do so and immediately fingerprinted. So I think that randomization might indeed be a bad idea in many cases.

Your link doesn't work though. I just get "file not found".

Re:The Tor Project is switching to Rust by ue7gjelwjd on Friday December 12, 2025 @03:31PM (#46248499)
Hacker News (and Rust proponents through voting brigades, like how Linus called out Rust proponents for social media brigading) censors and deletes good posts for the sake of protecting liars and harassers like Steve Klabnik. Hacker News has no shame and no honesty. Most Rust proponents have less than no respect for themselves,
Re:The Tor Project is switching to Rust by twhb on Saturday December 13, 2025 @03:06AM (#46252950)
Sorry, fixed link: https://demo.fingerprint.com/playground.

I agree on randomization, but there are other places where it doesn’t stick out like that. I’ll look up specifics if I find the time, but I think reading canvas data without permission is one place it’s utilized, including by Tor.

Re:The Tor Project is switching to Rust by monerozcash on Friday December 12, 2025 @01:37PM (#46247174)
It seems to reward totally unique randomized fingerprints also, which is maybe not great.
Re:The Tor Project is switching to Rust by ue7gjelwjd on Friday December 12, 2025 @03:31PM (#46248501)
Hacker News (and Rust proponents through voting brigades, like how Linus called out Rust proponents for social media brigading) censors and deletes good posts for the sake of protecting liars and harassers like Steve Klabnik. Hacker News has no shame and no honesty. Most Rust proponents have less than no respect for themselves;
Re:The Tor Project is switching to Rust by whytevuhuni on Friday December 12, 2025 @04:25PM (#46249162)
This is the 3rd copy of a flagged comment within a single minute.