News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Distributed ID Formats Are Architectural Commitments, Not... by orefalo on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @02:44AM (#46215171)
I wrote an article comparing different GUID implementations and also prepared a clear spreadsheet with side‑by‑side implementation comparisons.

https://medium.com/@orefalo_66733/globally-unique-identifier...

Looking at your implementation, I like the clean split between shard, tenant, and sequence.

However, this results in a 160‑bit format, which does not fit natively in most databases, as they usually use the UUID type. I also find 60 bits of randomness to be low (ULID also uses 60).

Last point, using a GUID is not only for sharding. It is also important for protecting against predictability, which beyond the GUID structure, requires using the right approved crypto‑safe random generator.

There are no comments on this comment yet.