> Yes it's like the wine glass thing.
No, it's not!
That's part of my point; the wine glass scenario is a _realistic_ scenario. The pelican riding a bike is not. It's a _huge_ difference. Why should we measure intelligence (...) in regards to something that is realistic and something that is unrealistic?
I just don't get it.
It is unrealistic because if you go to a restaurant, you don't get served a glass like that. It is frowned upon (alcohol is a drug, after all) and impractical (wine stains are annoying) to fill a glass of wine as such.
A pelican riding a bike, on the other hand, is realistic in a scenario because of TV for children. Example from 1950's animation/comic involving a pelican [1].
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Adventures_of_Paddy_the_Pe...
Since people look at a glass of wine and judge how much "value" they got based partly on how much wine it looks like, many bars and restaurants choose bad wine-glasses (for the purpose of enjoying wine) that are smalle and thus can be fulled more.
Yes it's like the wine glass thing.
Also it's kind of got depth. Does it draw the pelican and the bicycle? Can the penguin reach the peddles? How?
I can imagine a really good AI finding a funny or creative or realistic way for the penguin to reach the peddles.
An slightly worse AI will do an OK job, maybe just making the bike small or the legs too long.
An OK AI will draw a penguin on top of a bicycle and just call it a day.
It's not as binary as the wine glass example.