News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Android users outraged over Motorola's broken promise by ck2 on Saturday October 06, 2012 @08:56AM (#4620393)
They are not stuck at all. If they had bought an apple, microsoft or blackberry phone they would have been stuck.

But because they are on an open source android device they have cyanogenmod which is even better than stock and either has or has coming ICS for their model.

This is pretty revolutionary for mobile devices where you no longer are slaved to the manufacturer. Credit to google?

Re:Android users outraged over Motorola's broken promise by mdasen on Saturday October 06, 2012 @10:12AM (#4620567)
CyanogenMod doesn't exist for the Motorola Photon.

It's great to say that open source means you have the power, but most people can't reverse-engineer a driver.

In fact, it seems like none of the newer, popular Android devices are supported by CyanogenMod. Looking through the Android phones from the top three American carriers, I see:

Motorola: RAZR M, RAZR MAXX, RAZR, Photon Q 4G LTE, ADMIRAL, Atrix HD

Samsung: Galaxy S III, Galaxy Stellar, Stratosphere, Droid Charge, Galaxy Nexus, Conquer 4G, Replenish, Transform Ultra, Galaxy Victory, Galaxy S II (Sprint), Galaxy Note, Galaxy Exhilarate, Galaxy S II Skyrocket, Captivate Glide, Rugby Smart

LG: Intuition, Lucid, Spectrum, Enlighten, Optimus Elite, Optimus S, Viper 4G LTE, Escape, Nitro HD

HTC: Incredible 4G LTE, Rhyme, Rezound, Hero, One X, Vivid

Pantech: Marauder, Breakout, Flex, Burst, Pocket

Casio: G'zOne Commando

Kyocera: Rise, Milano

ZTE: Fury

Sony: Xperia ion

That's a list of every Android phone offered by the big four American carriers. There isn't a single device for Sprint or Verizon (accounting for over half the market) that CyanogenMod supports. With AT&T, you're limited to the Galaxy S II Skyrocket (and, really, you'd want the S III). There's also not a device released in 2012 that CyanogenMod supports. CyanogenMod gave me a workable system at a time when Samsung abandoned my device having never fixed major bugs. However, with newer devices, CyanogenMod seems to be slipping behind. If you're buying a nice Android device today and putting out $200, you're getting something like a Galaxy S III, a One X, or a RAZR M and it isn't clear that you'll be getting much support for your device (from the manufacturer, carrier, Google, or third parties).

I bought into Android with high hopes. I understand how crappy Apple's closed model is. However, Android is making you beholden to the device manufacturer and your carrier in the same way iPhone users are beholden to Apple - unless you can reverse engineer device drivers. I know, in theory, you could hire someone or whatnot, but in practice Apple supports their devices for many years while Android phones may never see updates. Buying an Android phone has to be a purchase where you assume you won't even get an OS that exists today unless it's pre-loaded on the phone. Android manufacturers bought themselves a year of "but it's going to change" when they made the pledge. That pledge fell through as soon as it came time to actually provide the upgrades.

Saying that they aren't stuck is somewhat akin to saying that poor people could just go out and become rich. Sure, in theory, there are always opportunities and whatnot, but it just isn't that easy. In reality, Google didn't free us, but tethered us to manufacturers that care less and carriers that are even worse. If Google were to be credited here, I think they should have insisted on a model where device manufacturers release drivers (ala Windows) so that users could install Android from any source. Even better would be to have those drivers be open source so that users could update them (providing updates is going to be easier than reverse engineering). That would have led to real options.

Re:Android users outraged over Motorola's broken promise by drivebyacct2 on Saturday October 06, 2012 @02:11PM (#4621201)
>There isn't a single device for Sprint or Verizon

Uh, The Galaxy Nexus, SGSIII?

Re:Android users outraged over Motorola's broken promise by coopdog on Saturday October 06, 2012 @09:27AM (#4620456)
Actually the people who installed the last motorola patches actually had the ability to flash their phone removed with that patch, so they can't even install cyanogenmod.
Re:Android users outraged over Motorola's broken promise by nachteilig on Saturday October 06, 2012 @11:43AM (#4620780)
This may be a funny comment to find on HN, but even as a reasonbly technical person I really don't want to spend the time to find mods, research what my hypothetical Android phone is capable of running etc.

Especially because I depend on it to occasionally take a call and whatnot--I don't want to worry about whether some program or software update is going to screw it up. I worry enough about this stuff at work.

Nexus sort of solves this problem, but I hope that Google will do an even better job as Apple has now that they own Motorola.

Re:Android users outraged over Motorola's broken promise by reaganing on Saturday October 06, 2012 @09:24AM (#4620448)
This provides that you're a) a nerd, b) comfortable voiding your warranty by rooting the phone and c) that your phone is even popular enough for there to be things like Cyanogenmod to install on it.

Sure, I did that with my HTC Incredible, but I shouldn't have had too and most people won't.

Re:Android users outraged over Motorola's broken promise by shardling on Saturday October 06, 2012 @10:36AM (#4620620)
Sure, but regular folk don't seem to be up in arms over the lack of updates.
Re:Android users outraged over Motorola's broken promise by inportb on Saturday October 06, 2012 @10:01AM (#4620533)
You don't need to be a nerd; you only need access to someone you trust who would do it for you. And plenty of folks wait until their warranty runs out before modifying the OS.
Re:Android users outraged over Motorola's broken promise by micampe on Saturday October 06, 2012 @10:11AM (#4620561)
how long until the updated version of this? http://www.thinkgeek.com/product/388b/