News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fend Off Trolls, Bots and Jerks With ‘Empathy’ Test by wamatt on Friday October 05, 2012 @10:23PM (#4619530)
>"How does that make you feel"

Mu.

Obviously it's dead simple to guess the 'correct' answer.

But wrapping it in a faux test of one's humanness is an off-putting premise, that can come across morally condescending (which probably wasn't the intention).

While I support civil rights and the group behind it is probably well intentioned, it doesn't follow automatically that this instance of execution is a good idea.

Also, it's probably fallacious to assume only 3 emotions (or any at all for that matter), are occurring in the user.

"meh", "bored" or "mildly annoyed" etc, are perfectly valid answers too, and does not mean we are jerks for feeling that way :p

Re:Fend Off Trolls, Bots and Jerks With ‘Empathy’ Test by jamestc on Friday October 05, 2012 @11:23PM (#4619664)
I agree. It's a pretty shallow idea. Is it a terrible thing to be "fascinated" by something that is supposedly terrible? Fascination doesn't actually necessitate a polarized reaction. And, really, exclusionary tactics/gatekeeping with opinions? These seem like awfully short-sighted solutions to a deeper problem.

And, what's more, trolls aren't hard to mobilize if provoked. Start implementing this and I wouldn't doubt seeing a small movement devoted to going the extra mile to offend people with "humane" sensibilities.