News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Scala 3 slowed us down? by jll29 on Monday December 08, 2025 @06:00AM (#46190905)
A language should not be complicated. (Wish Odersky, capable as he is, kept working on his much-verlooked TurboModula).

Simple:

- Scheme

- C

- Pascal

- Go

- Lua

Complicated

- PL/1

- C++ 2024

- Scala 3

Still borderline or beyond?

- Rust

- Java (>850 pp. lang. specification...)

Re:Scala 3 slowed us down? by still_grokking on Monday December 08, 2025 @04:47PM (#46198101)
Extremely weird list.

The Scala spec is much shorter than the C spec… Also it's of course much shorter than Rust, where nobody has a real issue with its complexity, at least nobody is complaining really loudly.

The C and Go specs are actually extremely involved, long, and complex given that the languages almost don't have any features at all.

But comparing language specs isn't a 100% fair metric.

One should instead look at formal language semantic definitions written all in the same way.

If you look at these you will for example learn that the C semantics are much more complex than for example Java.

Check out https://kframework.org/ to learn more. (A list of semantics for different languages can be found on the "projects" sub page).