News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Programming peaked by frumplestlatz on Thursday December 04, 2025 @06:25PM (#46154698)
> Instead of trying to hear understand and challenge what historians have to say

One self-described historian. On a Reddit post. Let’s not pretend this is the unified or authoritative voice of the discipline.

> I could go on with fashion and clothes but maybe just look at a West European king painting to reevaluate what masculinity is supposed to look like traditionally.

You’re conflating aesthetic masculinity with functional masculinity, and that’s a category error. The aphorism isn’t about how men dressed in the 17th century or how they signaled status — it’s about what kind of men can sustain a civilization.

In this context, “strong men” refers to individuals who demonstrate the discipline, competence, long-term responsibility, and willingness to bear risk that are required to build, maintain, and defend the institutions that keep a society stable — especially when conditions are difficult. It’s a sociological concept, not an aesthetic one, and it has nothing to do with your personal distaste (or favor) for particular cultural aesthetic expressions of masculinity.

There are no comments on this comment yet.