GM was the only problem because Ford wasn't in trouble and Chrysler was (and still is) negligible.
> auto industry is highly concentrated in a single geographic area
Most "US made cars" are not made in Michigan.... "In 2011 , the Detroit Region produced 1.56 million vehicles, accounting for nearly 82% of Michigan's motor vehicle production, over 18% of the United State's motor vehicle production, and nearly 12% of North America's motor vehicle production. Currently more than 151,000 metro Detroiters work in the automotive and auto-related industries." http://www.detroitchamber.com/component/content/article/14-a...
US auto suppliers sell to all companies that make cars in the US.
> Who would be left then to use these assets? Some unnamed US automotive company?
Not necessarily - there are folks who could have afforded the assets. (Penske is a minor player and they made a serious bid for Saturn.)
Note that GM was selling cars for more money than it cost to make them - the problem was the legacy liabilities, liabilities which they'd have shed in ordinary bankruptcy.
The "bailout" money was a political payoff. It mainly went to keep the UAW pensions solvent and GM shut down Saturn as a sweetener. (The UAW always hated Saturn, even after organizing it.)
Why do you assume that the supply chain would have broken down?
> it's very hard to argue that they were a net loss on U.S. GDP unless you assume a "controlled bankrupcy" for GM and Chrysler would not have destroyed the U.S. (or global) auto industry. That's a big leap.
It's easy to assume that standard bankruptcy would not have destroyed the US auto industry because there's no reason why it would have destroyed the US auto industry.
Bankruptcy is basically about separating assets from liabilities.
If GM's assets are well-suited to profitably making cars, that's what they'd have been used for post-bankruptcy. Why do you assume otherwise?
US airlines go bankrupt every so often. Their creditors take a loss but the effect on the rest of us is that a few flights get cancelled and that's about it.