What certain phrases?
(p.s. You don't need to link me to the HN guidelines, by the way. It just comes off as condescending. I'm on the site, I know where to find the guidelines, and you quoted the guideline in question verbatim. I don't understand why people do this.)
Or, … they're just citing the source for the information, so that, in case you aren't aware as to where to find them, now you are.
I think that's a doubly reasonable thing to do, given that your account is new, too.
The guidelines are linked at the bottom of every page, and directly underneath the comment box on new accounts. I also, perhaps surprisingly, know how to google "hn guidelines". Or ask chatgpt. Or reply "where's that piece of information from?".
>I think that's a doubly reasonable thing to do, given that your account is new, too.
People link the guidelines and, like, wikipedia to accounts that are 10 years old with 30,000 karma. It's a weird quirk of HN.
If you're talking to someone in real life, or professional emails, or whatever and you provide citations for commonly known things/definitions/etc.... you're being condescending.
If you're commenting on a public forum and you provide citations for commonly known things/definitions/etc., you're supplying the source of your claims for people who may be unaware. You are not the only reader of their comment (nor this one), even if it is in direct reply to yours.
[1] https://www.dictionary.com/browse/no [2] https://www.dictionary.com/browse/you [3] https://www.dictionary.com/browse/are [4] https://www.dictionary.com/browse/being [5] https://www.dictionary.com/browse/condescending
Assuming everyone is an idiot who a) doesn't know something common and b) isn't able to figure out how to google it and c) isn't able to figure out how to say "where's that from?" in a reply is condescending [6].
> Assuming everyone is an idiot who a) doesn't know something common and b) isn't able to figure out how to google it and c) isn't able to figure out how to say "where's that from?" in a reply
These things were neither assumed nor implied.
Dear jfindper,
I hope this professional email finds you well.
Would you mind reading about HN's approach to comments and site guidelines?
https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html
Please don't fulminate. Please don't sneer, including at the rest of the community.
Kind regards,
A. Webshitter
The Wiz post has significantly changed since it was first published (and how it looked when first posted to HN), FYI -- see [1]. When it was published, it was a summary of the React announcement, and was somehow longer than the original and yet provided less useful information than the original.
In any case, the "tell" is the syntactic structure (as Chomsky would say) and certain phrases used in the post.
[0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
[1]: https://web.archive.org/web/20251203162416/https://www.wiz.i...