BTW, you've failed to substantiate your claim that the market fails to pick efficient winners and losers. How would you even define "efficient" without appealing to the marketplace?
Clever rhetorical trick.
> BTW, you've failed to substantiate your claim that the market fails to pick efficient winners and losers. How would you even define "efficient" without appealing to the marketplace?
It's not a claim that requires substantiation, it's common knowledge: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Market_failure#Externalities
And then there's the whole "regulatory capture" thing.
Govts fail all the time.
And he's right because the free market has far more diversity. To put it another way, govt is pretty much the definition of systemic risk.
The free market has folks doing lots of different things. Some think that electric cars are the way to go while others stick with gas. Still others go with compressed air.
Govts don't make diverse bets and they're a lot slower to change course when things don't work (because the folks benefiting from the current plan aren't paying its costs).
Yes, "all the wood behind one arrow" can be more efficient, but only when everything works out, which is not all that often.
"Let 1000 flowers bloom" works much better in the real world.
Also, I'd arguing that taxing a particular form of energy is equivalent to picking a loser.