This system is mostly self-balancing.
The real question at stake here is do we want to hold back real algorithmic innovation that we actually want? Of course we need to have alarms to head-off flash crashes, but we want a lot of great people working on getting information into the market as fast as possible right? I mean the end goal as I see it is the replace of most traders to algorithms that bring prices closer to market with better/faster information.
Also, you're just wrong about the reason the market exists. The market is just as much about people trying to raise money as it is about people wanting to transfer risk.
> There was plenty of liquidity in the 90's and before to fulfill that function, even with the huge spreads back then
Are you saying things were great back then? why would anyone want to pay huge spreads?
is that really the best argument you have?
seriously, reread your comment. now apply it to online shopping, telephone systems, satellites, air traffic control, etc. it applies to literally everything involving technology. should it all be banned?