News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Putting the Brakes on High Frequency Trading by damoncali on Wednesday October 03, 2012 @10:32PM (#4610630)
When one market participant breaks the market with his crappy program, that's a huge problem for the companies that use the public markets to raise money - the entire reason the markets exist. There was plenty of liquidity in the 90's and before to fulfill that function, even with the huge spreads back then. You are missing the forest for the trees.
Re:Putting the Brakes on High Frequency Trading by flyinglizard on Wednesday October 03, 2012 @10:37PM (#4610635)
Breaking the market with a crappy program costs the responsible firm tons of money, up to a complete insolvency.

This system is mostly self-balancing.

Re:Putting the Brakes on High Frequency Trading by damoncali on Wednesday October 03, 2012 @10:39PM (#4610648)
Mostly. Until it isn't. It only takes one really bad screw up to cause a boatload of damage.
Re:Putting the Brakes on High Frequency Trading by icelancer on Wednesday October 03, 2012 @10:55PM (#4610684)
To the firm who is responsible. If they are buying up securities at well below-market rates, the problem solves itself.
Re:Putting the Brakes on High Frequency Trading by damoncali on Wednesday October 03, 2012 @11:01PM (#4610700)
And anyone relying on that firm. What happens if a major bank pulls a Knight and blinks out of existence? Can this happen? I don't know. The answer to that question should be an emphatic "no."
Re:Putting the Brakes on High Frequency Trading by nickpinkston on Wednesday October 03, 2012 @10:41PM (#4610652)
There are already triggers in place now to stop trading when it gets out of reasonable bounds not right? Say like a x% shift throws an alarm that halts orders until a human looks at the situation, etc. I like the ticking exchanges (like the FTSE does not right?) where it "ticks" on the microsecond or some such so some of the clever hacks (locating near the datacenter) are eliminated.

The real question at stake here is do we want to hold back real algorithmic innovation that we actually want? Of course we need to have alarms to head-off flash crashes, but we want a lot of great people working on getting information into the market as fast as possible right? I mean the end goal as I see it is the replace of most traders to algorithms that bring prices closer to market with better/faster information.

Re:Putting the Brakes on High Frequency Trading by damoncali on Wednesday October 03, 2012 @10:50PM (#4610671)
I would disagree. We do not need innovation. We need stable functioning markets, which is a goal that is in direct conflict with innovative trading. The system, and the participants' confidence in that system is of far greater importance than the efficiency of the system, and infinitely more important than the opportunity for some smart computer guys to make a buck doing essentially nothing of value. "As fast as possible" should not be the goal. "As fast as necessary" should be, and we are well beyond that.
Re:Putting the Brakes on High Frequency Trading by andylei on Wednesday October 03, 2012 @11:10PM (#4610727)
YOU are missing the forest for the trees. When the a stock is misvalued for about twenty minutes on the public markets, NO ONE raising money in the public markets (in the form of IPOs or secondary offerings) loses money. Not a single one.

Also, you're just wrong about the reason the market exists. The market is just as much about people trying to raise money as it is about people wanting to transfer risk.

> There was plenty of liquidity in the 90's and before to fulfill that function, even with the huge spreads back then

Are you saying things were great back then? why would anyone want to pay huge spreads?

Re:Putting the Brakes on High Frequency Trading by damoncali on Wednesday October 03, 2012 @11:12PM (#4610733)
Why do you assume small, temporary mispricings are the worst that can happen? It's all connected.
Re:Putting the Brakes on High Frequency Trading by andylei on Wednesday October 03, 2012 @11:23PM (#4610762)
>> It's all connected.

is that really the best argument you have?

Re:Putting the Brakes on High Frequency Trading by damoncali on Wednesday October 03, 2012 @11:32PM (#4610783)
Yep. I believe that the stability of the markets is of vital importance to civilized society, and computers (among other things) can endanger that system when used recklessly. We have clear evidence that the people writing this code often enough do not give a shit. And that is a problem. I'm just saying that there ought to be some thought put into how much we need to push innovative techniques when the stakes are so high. We almost broke everything in 2008 with derivatives and leverage. We out to think about how similarly scoped problems can arise when mathematicians are allowed to get creative before it happens. It only takes once.
Re:Putting the Brakes on High Frequency Trading by andylei on Thursday October 04, 2012 @04:55AM (#4611479)
none of the things you said describe a mechanism for how hft can topple society / endanger markets / other non specific harms.

seriously, reread your comment. now apply it to online shopping, telephone systems, satellites, air traffic control, etc. it applies to literally everything involving technology. should it all be banned?

Re:Putting the Brakes on High Frequency Trading by damoncali on Thursday October 04, 2012 @08:45AM (#4611995)
I never said HFT. I said out of control computer algorithms. The point is that the markets should not tolerate cowboy coders breaking things in a way that endagers the whole system. Knight failed catastrophically. There is your mechanism. No go apply that to a larger, more unstable part of the market. What if Knight was BofA? Bad things can happen, and if the best argument for this sort of thing is "liquidity", thanks, but no thanks. We have enough of that already. I'm all for letting people gamble when they are the ones who take the loss. But we know that is just not how Wall St works at present time. That needs to change.
Re:Putting the Brakes on High Frequency Trading by bd_at_rivenhill on Wednesday October 03, 2012 @11:22PM (#4610758)
Any electronic trading system is capable of experiencing severe errors that have nothing to do with HFT; some of the most common examples involve manually keying an incorrect price or size for an outgoing order. The sort of safety mechanisms implemented by the exchange (which shouldn't permit errors by member firms from damaging the market) to prevent these sort of problems are similar to the sort of mechanisms that can prevent crashes from faulty automatic trading programs.