Re:Putting the Brakes on High Frequency Trading
by pash on Wednesday October 03, 2012 @10:33PM
(#4610631)
The real problem is that your "stop loss" is a standing order to sell, at any price, if the price of your asset falls below some threshold. That is fundamentally a bad idea, and it's just this sort of trading behavior that creates liquidity crises.
Re:Putting the Brakes on High Frequency Trading
by damoncali on Wednesday October 03, 2012 @10:38PM
(#4610639)
No, the real problem is that one person's program broke and caused real losses for other people who were acting rationally. If you must account for a non-zero chance that some geek's algorithm will go totally batshit and lose you a bunch of money in unpredictable ways, there is a huge problem at the very core of the marketplace.
Unfortunately for you, your brokerage's computer saw the price drop, executed your stop-loss order, and put your shares up for sale, which were then purchased by another 'liquidity provider' (or hell, maybe even the same one that caused the value to drop in the first place). You've now lost $1500 because of HFT. Your trade can't be reverted, because fuck you, that's why, but the holy "market makers" get their trades rolled back so that their rich friends don't suffer anything for their alogrithmic fail.