Re:OCaml maintainers reject massive AI-generated pull request
by suspended_state on Saturday November 29, 2025 @01:23PM
(#46089598)
Reading through the article, it says:
> Shinwell also consulted AI regarding the copyright, which told him that “I conclude that no code was copied from oxcaml” and gave reasons. Unconvinced, maintainer Gabriel Scherer said “the fact that the tool that produced the code attributes its copyright to a real human is a clear sign that something is an issue.”
This is inaccurate, Mark Shinwell didn't participate to the discussion, and if he somehow consulted AI, it is not mentioned anywhere in the discussion. Actually, the AI analysis was performed by the PR submitter.
The topic of the article has been discussed in another HN submission:
Re:OCaml maintainers reject massive AI-generated pull request
by stefan_ on Saturday November 29, 2025 @02:20PM
(#46090019)
This is AI blog slop about someone submitting AI slop merge requests without reading any of it, instead expecting maintainers to do it. Quite the irony.
> Shinwell also consulted AI regarding the copyright, which told him that “I conclude that no code was copied from oxcaml” and gave reasons. Unconvinced, maintainer Gabriel Scherer said “the fact that the tool that produced the code attributes its copyright to a real human is a clear sign that something is an issue.”
This is inaccurate, Mark Shinwell didn't participate to the discussion, and if he somehow consulted AI, it is not mentioned anywhere in the discussion. Actually, the AI analysis was performed by the PR submitter.
The topic of the article has been discussed in another HN submission:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46039274