And similarly obviously classifieds didn't have even remotely near the same reach. Classifieds were an opt-in categorized system that was delivered to a small subset of classified viewers that was, itself, a small subset of all newspaper subscribers in society. And you're paying for small lines of text delivered to this opt-in audience as opposed to as opposed to graphical images, or even videos, imposed on people against their will.
Its not magic, but spending on certain types of things do increase with GDP. Insisting that they don't, despite the evidence that they do historically because it is inconvenient for your argument isn't convincing.
> And similarly obviously classifieds didn't have even remotely near the same reach.
You are claiming that a classified in 1970 would not routinely reach tens of thousands of people?
> as opposed to graphical images, or even videos, imposed on people against their will
The nature of advertising has changes and I don't really doubt it has been made more harmful. What I don't see is a line between that and your fantastical claim that the internet is somehow a net negative.
Classifieds had extremely limited reach and advertising was practically impossible in them due to the categorized/opt-in nature. Nobody in this world wants to be bombarded with endless ads, yet most of every tech company wants to bombard people with endless ads. It's a highly adversarial relationship that just doesn't work in the domain of something like classifieds where you're not even seeing them unless you actively go to the classified pages, and then dig into them and find something under a specific category.
You are claiming that the increased spending on advertising is due to the internet. The relationship between GDP and ad spending pretty clearly indicates that the internet was not the cause of increased ad spend, except in as much as it increased GDP.
If the internet has any effect on ad spend growth, you would have seen the growth rates of GDP and ad spend diverge with the birth of the internet.
To see how clearly wrong you are consider this, part of GDP growth is population growth. You are claiming that population growth is irrelevant to ad spend growth?
> It should be beyond obvious that this has basically no relationship whatsoever to modern advertising.
Even your own numbers pretty clearly indicate that the pricing can be equivalent, which was my point.
You need to work on your reading comprehension.
You could buy a classified with the same or better reach and same price in 1980.
> Your GDP thing is a complete red herring. GDP has no relevance on the meaning of increases in advertising.
You've claimed that internet cause ad spending to grow. Ad spending only grew because the GDP grew so you can't blame the internet for it.
> Yes it is increasing exponentially
Again, because GDP is increasing exponentially.
Also your graph doesn't show total spend, only the breakdown by sector.