News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Cell So Minimal That It Challenges Definitions of Life by mncharity on Wednesday November 26, 2025 @08:06PM (#46064271)
First, context: a "life/not-life" distinction is far more "science" than science - widespread in "science" education, but rarely comes up in science research. (Might be interesting to create a list of similar?) Why the emphasis there... I don't know - perhaps because we teach by memorizing definitions and lists, not by learning design spaces and their landmarks? Or at least giving exemplars without characterizing variance.

One of the few places I've seen it come up in science, was multi-scale ecosystem simulation software. Where virus was squarely in the heritable characteristics under selection pressure ("life") bucket, rather than abiotic or biogenic.

Informal "do you think of viruses as alive?" seems to vary by field. I've seen a marine bio department be overwhelmingly yes. I've been told medical immunology leans no. But it's more social-media engagement question than research result.

There are no comments on this comment yet.