Ask HN: Don't show points?
Psychologically, people naturally follow groupthink. No matter how much you stress not following it, they'll still be inclined to follow the herd.
So just saying "try not to follow groupthink" isn't good enough. Instead, why not make it less possible to follow groupthink?
So here's my suggestion: stop displaying the points. Maybe still gray out downvoted comments, but I think even that is unnecessary. They'll float down to the bottom of the thread anyway. And I know that when I see a downvoted thread, I read it differently. I don't say "maybe a couple people just didn't like what they said, and it was actually ok" coming into it, I say "what did this person do wrong? What stupid thing did they say?" I come into it biased because of the points it has.
Same goes for a comment with a lot of points. I say, "what great wisdom does this person have for me?" and thus am naturally more inclined to upvote it or at least like it.
The rankings would still work the same, so the good comments would still float to the top, but there wouldn't be an absolute number to tell you "this is amazing" or "this sucks." High posts might just be very new. Low posts might just have gone unnoticed or been overshadowed by more amazing ones.
I realize that the points serve many positive purposes too, and it's just an idea, but I think if individual, unprejudiced discussions are what we want, eliminating the display of points would help a lot.
It really depends on whether you see yourself as a Hacker News reader, or as a Hacker News editor. It's just like Amazon: If I'm a customer, I want to hear what everyone else thinks about something. But if I were hiring someone to be a professional reviewer for Amazon, I'd hide the other ratings to make them as objective as possible.
So here are two ways ratings make HN a more pleasant experience:
- If I have limited time to go through HN, I want to be able to zoom in on the comments others judged to be of the highest quality.
- If the comment is on a topic I have little familiarity with, it's often hard to judge its accuracy/validity on my own. A decent number of votes gives me confidence that the person is right.
So in these respects, it's just like Google rankings or Amazon ratings.
Having points probably does cause some amount of groupthink. I bet hiding votes would scrunch the distribution of votes around the mean.
By the way, if HN's database contains the exact sequence of upmods/downmods for a particular story, e.g. 1, 1, -1, -1, -1, 1, ..., it would be possible to test how much groupthink is involved by modeling the sequence of votes as a random walk and testing how much the probability of an upmod/downmod is conditional on the current number of votes. Or, if HN starts hiding votes, you could analyze how this affects voting patterns. Sounds like an interesting college stats/psychology project for someone :)
When I vote (here), I'm pushing a comment towards an idealized score. To make the decisions "do I think this is rated too highly" and "do I think this is rated too lowly" requires knowledge of the current score.
The reason that you would want to show the score before voting is that HN isn't all about voting and karma. If someone were to just want to read the best answers to a question, they might just scan by score for the highest ones.
Maybe there could be a manual-override for one page. But it would make you be conscious of the fact that you're going to bias yourself by doing it. It would be for people wanting to read but not really vote.
So sure you may not know that something is at 1 or 500 points, but you you sure can guess
Vote counts give me more information. While that may affect my understanding of an idea, it's for the better.
Points may have an inherent bias towards older posts or well known authors, but I value what they represent.
So as of now, that information you're using is unreliable because it is affected by groupthink.
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=447563
I tend to find myself influenced by the karma count more than anything else. I have to log myself out after commenting to increase the cost of checking the change to my net karma.
I'm a strong advocate of hiding the karma counts entirely (for users, submissions, and comments). That greatly reduces the conditioning effect, not to mention karma-related drama and groupthink (as Surowiecki argues, crowd wisdom is best procured when evaluations are performed independently). Submissions and comments can still be ordered by net karma over time, as they are now.
Whatever you choose to do, I think there's a strong argument in favor of experimentalism. Especially since the site isn't a commercial undertaking and can deal with the occasional disruption.
(Um, and yes, that user is me. I locked myself out of my account to keep myself from compulsively commenting and visiting the site. Apparently I still wanted back in.)
In what way do you think he is "dictating" guidelines?
... except that a few times, I've observed my attitude towards a comment change when its score changed. What is a little frightening is I have also witnessed a struggle within me between what seems to be true to me, and fitting in with the group's opinion.
This psychological phenomenon has been confirmed experimentally (though I have met one extremely detached person (borderline autistic?) who I would bet would be above it). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asch_conformity_experiments
A struggle for perception of reality is a struggle for reality.
As far as "handling the truth" I don’t think that speaks to his point. When we use that phrase we are talking about someone controlling their reaction to a change they can perceive. Such as someone preventing themselves from emotionally falling apart when something bad happens.
But group think, and the desire for acceptance which is its root cause, is something people don’t perceive is happening to them. They therefore can’t consciously control their reaction to it.
His suggestion is that we remove the root stimuli so as to not provoke the reaction to begin with. So your point doesn’t really apply.
The modding system is useful for ranking comments so that when I read a massive thread the most interesting ones tend to be around the top.
It may also be useful for users as a feedback mechanism to figure out when they're doing something that's not cool (like the things we've been discussing in the guidelines thread today) but I don't think you need a precise numerical score for that. And I think it's the precise score that gets people in the karma-game mindset. It certainly does that for me.
The problem is that pretty much everyone is in some way influenced by them just by seeing them.
Do you really approach a comment at -10 points with the same open mind as one with +30?
The problem is you don’t know the moral character or intelligence level of the people who first stumbled on to a comment. If two ignorant people happen to see a quality comment first and both vote it down that comment is essentially lost to the group. I think we can all agree there are at least a few fools running around here so the idea isn’t farfetched.
So the question is do you want to trust what might be insightful comments to the randomness of timing?
If the comment was really sparkling, it seems unlikely that the first two ignoramuses would drown out the larger cast of HN. It's not all about timing.
Also, 10 people on a site that gets in the area of 200,000 uniques isn't that significant.
upmods - downmods = score
Unfortunately they tend to turn in to a goal by themselves.
Points are the root of all evil ;)
It's a classic case of influencing the system that you are measuring, same with google pagerank or a volt meter with a low internal resistance.
But perhaps it would be better not to be confronted with your score every time you log in.