There are a ton of basically BS office jobs that could probably be replaced by AI, or in some cases just revealed as superfluous.
We need to just stop pretending we still need a 1:1 connection between employment and income and do UBI. Useless jobs help us preserve the illusions of a pre-post-industrial civilization. Instead of just paying people, we pay people to do work we don't need.
Something went wrong once. Maybe not even in your organization, but it went wrong somewhere. Someone added a process to make sure that the problem didn't happen again, because that's what well-run organizations are supposed to do.
But too often, people don't think about the cost of the procedure. People are going to have to follow this procedure every time the situation happens for the next N years. How much does that cost in peoples' time? In money? How much did the mistake cost? How often did it happen? So was the procedure a net gain or a net loss? People don't ask that, but instead the procedure gets written and becomes "industry best practice".
(And for some industries, it is! Aviation, medical, defense... some of those have really tight regulation, and they require strict procedures. But not every organization is in those worlds...)
So now you have poor corporate drones that have to run through that maze of procedures, over and over. Well, if GPT can run the maze for you, that's really tempting. It can cut your boredom and tedium, cut out a ton of meaningless work, and make you far faster.
But on the other hand, if you are the person who wrote the procedure, you think that it matters that it be done correctly. The form has to be filled out accurately, not with random gibberish, not even with correct-sounding-but-not-actually-accurate data. So you cannot allow GPT to do the procedures.
The procedure-writers and procedure-doers live in different worlds and have different goals, and GPT doesn't fix that at all.
Which is really just making a ton of people waste their time doing bullshit work. I fail to see how this is progressive.
But then I remembered how dehumanizing meaningless jobs are, and... I'm not sure how much of a win either direction is.
- Even without AI most corpos could shed probably 10% of their workforce - or maybe more - and still be about as productive as they are now. Bunch of reasons why that's true, but here are two I can easily think of: (1) after the layoffs work shifts to the people who remain, who then work harder; (2) underperformers are often not let go for a long time or ever because their managers don't want to do the legwork (and the layoffs are a good opportunity to force that to happen).
- It's hard for leadership to initiate layoffs, because doing so seems like it'll make the company look weak to investors, customers, etc. So if you really want to cut costs by shedding 10%+ of your workforce and making the remaining 90% work harder, then you have to have a good story to tell for why you are doing it.
- AI makes for a good story. It's a way to achieve what you would have wanted to achieve anyway, while making it seem like you're cutting edge.