If you're being overly literal, yes, the <>s are needed here for this exact syntax. My point was not about this specific example, it's that these forms are equivalent, but some of them are syntactically simpler than others. The existence of redundant forms does not make the syntax illegitimate, or overly complex.
For this specific issue, if square brackets were used for generics, then something else would have to change for array indexing, and folks would be complaining that Rust doesn't do what every other language does here, which is its own problem.
The compiler knows when the `A` in `A[B]` is a type vs a variable.
Anyway, just to be clear: not liking the turbofish is fine, it's a subjective preference. But it's not an objective win, that's all I'm saying. And it's only one small corner of Rust's syntax, so I don't think that removing it would really alleviate the sorts of broad objections that the original parent was talking about.
But then people would grouse about it using left-bracket and right-bracket as brackets in a type "context".
// nice and clean
let a = Generic[T, A > B]::new();
// gross curlies needed because of poor choices
let a = Generic::<T, {A > B}>::new();
It's practically your job to defend Rust, so I don't expect you to budge even one inch. However, I hate the idea of letting you mislead the casual reader that this is somehow equivalent and "just how languages work".
The grammar could've used `Generic[Specific]` with square brackets and avoided the need for the turbo fish.