Re:ISPs more likely to throttle netizens who connect through...
by protocolture on Sunday November 23, 2025 @11:13PM
(#46030313)
>Every ISP that I have experienced, mobile and broadband, is using CGNAT. The easiest way I’ve seen this on broadband is https://iknowwhatyoudownload.com/ showing several movie downloads per day.
From memory, APNIC was handing out a /22 to every new member, then a /23, then a /23 worth. Now it asks you to submit a plan on how you would allocate a /23 if you received those ips.
Re:ISPs more likely to throttle netizens who connect through...
by gruez on Sunday November 23, 2025 @10:48PM
(#46030163)
>and blocked with hCAPTCHA frequently (normally presented dishonestly with their stock page as “example.com needs to review the security of your connection before proceeding”
Isn't that from cloudflare, not hcaptcha?
Re:ISPs more likely to throttle netizens who connect through...
by chrismorgan on Sunday November 23, 2025 @11:44PM
(#46030469)
I meant, in the context: blocked by Cloudflare with hCAPTCHA recourse. But as I consider it more carefully, I don’t think they don’t use hCAPTCHA in their challenges any more. They used reCAPTCHA at first, moved to hCAPTCHA around 2020, then they made their own thing Turnstile in ~2022 and migrated challenges to that at probably? the same time.
Every ISP that I have experienced, mobile and broadband, is using CGNAT. The easiest way I’ve seen this on broadband is https://iknowwhatyoudownload.com/ showing several movie downloads per day.
Cloudflare isn’t the only problem, but they are the worst, probably by dint of popularity. I get blocked outright occasionally (presented dishonestly as because my request matched attack patterns due to things like SQL injection in query string parameters, when I’m actually just trying to load any regular page), and blocked with hCAPTCHA frequently (normally presented dishonestly with their stock page as “example.com needs to review the security of your connection before proceeding”, though a few like blender.org customise it). It’s draining.
In Cloudflare’s actual article, they claim their bot detection to be resilient to CGNAT <https://blog.cloudflare.com/detecting-cgn-to-reduce-collater...>. Frankly, if it is so, I wonder if they just have a rule that amounts to “is user in India”. I definitely feel prejudged and discriminated against. I am idly curious if leasing a static IP from my ISP would help anything, in the short or long term.
In Australia, I think I experienced Cloudflare’s blocking page once in my life, and no others.