Re:More whiteboard coding won’t build you a better team
by randometc on Tuesday October 02, 2012 @12:35PM
(#4602811)
Has someone suggested whiteboard proficiency is sufficient by itself?
Fair point, that is a straw man. I haven't experienced an all-whiteboard interview - there's always been more to it.
The whiteboard is meant to filter out people who suck.
I think that's what some interviewers have missed. They jump straight in at the deep end with difficult algorithmic puzzles, and don't ever do an easy one. I have experienced this.
Re:More whiteboard coding won’t build you a better team
by danielweber on Tuesday October 02, 2012 @12:41PM
(#4602849)
They jump straight in at the deep end with difficult algorithmic puzzles, and don't ever do an easy one. I have experienced this
Yeah, I have hard algorithm questions I ask, but I don't open with them, and I know they are hard. I expect them to possibly fill the entire remaining time.
Also, for the hard question, it's not even about getting it "right": the one person I ever had get my hardest question right was flushed by other people in my process, and I've hired many people who never got close. I want to see how they try.
Has someone suggested whiteboard proficiency is sufficient by itself?
The whiteboard is meant to filter out people who suck. "Add a cache to a JavaScript function" is a dumb question for reasons many others have pointed out. Joel's classic article[1] recommends these as examples:
• Write a function that determines if a string starts with an upper-case letter A-Z
• Write a function that determines the area of a circle given the radius
• Add up all the values in an array
Those are all trivial. You should be able to come up with another half-dozen if you sit and think for a bit. The language doesn't matter, and the syntax shouldn't matter (as compared to the semantics).
I hear lots of scare-stories of "great coders who choke on interviews," but I find it very hard to believe any kind of "great coder" can't add up the values in an array. I might ask "how do you find the median value in the array" just to see what they come up with. There isn't a right answer, but there are lots wrong answers.
[1] http://www.joelonsoftware.com/articles/GuerrillaInterviewing...