News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We should all be using dependency cooldowns by xg15 on Friday November 21, 2025 @03:31PM (#46008631)
It's a good idea, but not without weak points, I think.

One of the classic scammer techniques is to introduce artificial urgency to prevent the victim from thinking clearly about a proposal.

I think this would be a weakness here as well: If enough projects adopt a "cooldown" policy, the focus of attackers would shift to manipulate projects into making an exception for "their" dependency and install it before the regular cooldown period elapsed.

How to do that? By playing the security angle once again: An attacker could make a lot of noise how a new critical vulnerability was discovered in their project and every dependant should upgrade to the emergency release as quickly as possible, or else - with the "emergency release" then being the actually compromised version.

I think a lot of projects would could come under pressure to upgrade, if the perceived vulnerability seems imminent and the only point for not upgrading is some generic cooldown policy.

Re:We should all be using dependency cooldowns by __MatrixMan__ on Friday November 21, 2025 @03:46PM (#46008786)
Along those lines: If you're packaging an exploit, it's probably best to fix a bug while you're at it. That way people who want to remove their ugly workarounds will be motivated to violate the dependency cooldown.
Re:We should all be using dependency cooldowns by mewpmewp2 on Friday November 21, 2025 @04:33PM (#46009241)
How would they create that noise?
Re:We should all be using dependency cooldowns by xg15 on Friday November 21, 2025 @04:59PM (#46009472)
Depends on the level of infiltration I guess. If the attacker managed to get themselves into a trusted position, as with the XZ backdoor, they could use the official communication channels of the project and possibility even file a CVE.

If it's "only" technical access, it would probably be harder.

Re:We should all be using dependency cooldowns by andix on Friday November 21, 2025 @05:33PM (#46009823)
If they file a CVE, they will draw a lot of attention from experts to the project. Even from people who never heard from this package before.