News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Git 3.0 Defaults to "main" Branch Instead of "master by nicole_express on Friday November 21, 2025 @01:42PM (#46007469)
Changing defaults is an interesting definition of censorship. It's not like you can't configure it to still use a master branch if you want to.
Re:Git 3.0 Defaults to "main" Branch Instead of "master by foobarkey on Friday November 21, 2025 @01:49PM (#46007546)
Saying a word is bad is pretty much the definition of censorship yes. Not the context it is used, not the implications when it is used but uncategorically BAD - it just breaks my somewhat autistic brain on the principle.

PS: I have an african wife and let me tell you she has no beef with the word, she will have more beef with me talking to the cashier in a way that is too friendly

Re:Git 3.0 Defaults to "main" Branch Instead of "master by elashri on Friday November 21, 2025 @04:11PM (#46009041)
> Saying a word is bad is pretty much the definition of censorship yes

So if I disagree with an argument you make (about anything) and say it is a bad argument then this will be censorship?

You don't know what does it mean to be censored.

Re:Git 3.0 Defaults to "main" Branch Instead of "master by nicole_express on Friday November 21, 2025 @01:55PM (#46007609)
See I'd say the definition of censorship is saying a word is bad and preventing you from saying it, even if you disagree.

And git isn't preventing you from having a master branch. In fact, they're providing instructions for people who prefer that.

Re:Git 3.0 Defaults to "main" Branch Instead of "master by foobarkey on Friday November 21, 2025 @02:01PM (#46007678)
Making you fee like less of a person for using the word is also censorship but in a more clever mean gaslighting way than a full order :)
Re:Git 3.0 Defaults to "main" Branch Instead of "master by pyth0 on Friday November 21, 2025 @02:08PM (#46007750)
This seems like a you problem. I have quite a few repos made before using "main" was the default in GitHub or Git. I have not changed them, and I have never spent more than 5 seconds thinking about it, let alone worrying about being considered "less of a person" because of it.
Re:Git 3.0 Defaults to "main" Branch Instead of "master by collingreen on Friday November 21, 2025 @02:56PM (#46008257)
Careful, you're almost arguing the points of "the other side" you seem to detest so much!
Re:Git 3.0 Defaults to "main" Branch Instead of "master by oluwie on Friday November 21, 2025 @03:46PM (#46008791)
you keep using that word but i don’t think it means what you think it means
Re:Git 3.0 Defaults to "main" Branch Instead of "master by ash_091 on Friday November 21, 2025 @07:54PM (#46010977)
In the spirit of genuine curiosity, who is making you feel like less of a person wrt the choice of main/master, and how are they doing that?

It sounds like you're saying that git maintainers are intending for you to feel like less of a person because you don't agree with their choice, but I don't understand how you arrived at that conclusion.

Re:Git 3.0 Defaults to "main" Branch Instead of "master by dragonwriter on Saturday November 22, 2025 @02:11PM (#46017378)
> Saying a word is bad is pretty much the definition of censorship yes. Not the context it is used, not the implications when it is used but uncategorically BAD

No expressing an opinion, eve ln an unqualified unconditional one, about a word is not the fee definition of censorship. Forcing others not to publish what you don't like is censorship (even if that dislike is based in context and conditions, and not unconditional opposition to a word.) Presenting an opinion is just presenting an opinion.

> it just breaks my somewhat autistic brain on the principle.

Yeah, you not liking an opinion doesn’t convert that opinion into censorship, either.