News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:CBP is monitoring US drivers and detaining those with sus... by ninetyninenine on Friday November 21, 2025 @09:29AM (#46004949)
Personally I feel that a spouse having an affair is one of the biggest violations of human morality ever. Significantly bigger than tracking my license plate. Strange that someone would come up with this example as if having an affair is some kind of moral right that is trivial in comparison to license plate tracking.

Imagine someone took a picture of your face and your license plate and ultimately did nothing with it because there are billions of license plates and photos of faces and ultimately your picture is just a data point in millions and people are just trying to do other things with said data.

Then imagine your wife fucking another man behind your back and then coming home pretending she loves you. Or maybe from this guys perspective he’s the one cheating and him getting caught via surveillance is a moral violation? Like why are people so into privacy? I get the overall implications of a surveillance state but I feel a lot of it comes down to that a lot of Americans just do a lot of bad shit and they don’t want to be surveilled.

I still support the whole if you’re on public property… anything goes… including license plate tracking.

Re:CBP is monitoring US drivers and detaining those with sus... by FireBeyond on Friday November 21, 2025 @12:59PM (#46006928)
Because people are human beings and not property? They're your spouse, not your possession, and still possess free agency.

Which is one of the reasons why (simplifying) we don't legislate morality, and it's not illegal to be an asshole.

What about divorce? The logical conclusion of your scenario is that divorce should be illegal too, as you made a huge commitment to your partner, and now you want to break it?

Re:CBP is monitoring US drivers and detaining those with sus... by ninetyninenine on Friday November 21, 2025 @02:55PM (#46008248)
When the fuck did I say human beings are property. If you want to discuss this issue don’t talk to me like I’m some sick inhumane monster.
Re:CBP is monitoring US drivers and detaining those with sus... by R_D_Olivaw on Saturday November 22, 2025 @10:11PM (#46020426)
You made a huge argument about YOUR_WIFE. That is possessive.

And the rest of your argument all stems from them what, sleeping with someone else?

Yeah, that's gut wrenching. But building a massive argument about "it's okay to spy on people bc they shouldn't be cheating on me" just reads kind of childish.

A human being doing what they want with their body doesn't necessitate a surveillance state.

Deep breaths.

Re:CBP is monitoring US drivers and detaining those with sus... by bitwalker on Friday November 21, 2025 @01:11PM (#46007041)
Nobody is out here arguing that privacy is important because they want to make it easier to get away with things that are immoral or criminal. The importance of privacy is in retaining as much control over what information you share with others as possible, especially with the public at large, corporations, and the government. The information you wish to control is typically the kind that is sensitive in nature: PII; browser history, authentication secrets; what banking institution(s) you use; what accounts you have and their identifiers; financial information (what assets do you have, what are they, and how much are they worth, likewise with debts); spending patterns (where you shop, how often, how much do you spend); political affiliation and activities; religious beliefs and activities; how often do you travel, where do you go, and how do you get there; what is your daily routine/schedule, and how frequently do you deviate from it, etc. The list goes on and on.

Some of that information you might be totally fine with anyone knowing, such as your political leanings or religious beliefs. Others might be deeply uncomfortable with that being shared with just anyone. I assume you'd agree with me that at least some of the information I listed above is unambiguously of the variety that deserves privacy, i.e. you control who has access to it, and when.

Some things that should be generally private (e.g. financial activity), might need to be conditionally shared with certain parties (e.g. the government) - you might be fine with the IRS knowing details about your financial activity for purposes of taxation, but be understandably pissed if you found out that they were then making that information freely available to anyone that asked - because they have taken away your control over that information. I'm not saying that is actually the case, it is just an example.

Lastly, the more information about yourself that is effectively public information (either because you don't keep it private, or someone else has made it public without your consent), the easier it is to uncover other things that you do consider private. If someone can monitor everywhere you go, they can build a picture of you as an individual. Maybe you don't share your religious beliefs with others unless asked, but if someone knows that, e.g., you go to a specific church every Wednesday and Sunday, they now know your specific denomination and that you are more involved than the sort of person that only shows up on Sunday mornings, or only once a month, or only on holidays, etc. That information can be used to target you, either for innocuous purposes like advertising products to you that sell predominantly to that demographic - or for more malicious purposes, like running a scam against you that appeals to your specific beliefs, or in some cases, violence. That may seem unlikely to you, but you may also benefit from not being a minority that is prone to being targeted in such a way - the right to privacy ensures that we retain control over the information that can be used to target or hurt us according to our own risk tolerance.