Re:Building more with GPT-5.1-Codex-Max
by embedding-shape on Thursday November 20, 2025 @04:05PM
(#45997735)
> it proves nothing
Correct, but I'm not sure anyone actually claimed it proved anything at all? To be entirely sure, I don't know what you're arguing against/for here.
Right... Which is why the "canary" idea doesn't make much sense. The fact that the model isn't paying attention to the canary instruction doesn't demonstrate that the model has stopped paying attention to some other instruction that's relevant to the task - it proves nothing. If anything, a better performing model should pay less attention to the canary since it becomes less and less relevant as the context is filled with tokens relevant to the task.