News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reforming the Patent System Toward a Minimalist System by tzs on Monday October 01, 2012 @04:05AM (#4595815)
Keep in mind, though, that the requirement is non-obviousness to one of ordinary skill in the art. Even if more than one team comes up with the same thing in the same time frame, it might still be non-obvious if those teams were geniuses and dozens of ordinary teams had also tried to solve the problem and failed.
Re:Reforming the Patent System Toward a Minimalist System by gojomo on Monday October 01, 2012 @05:02AM (#4595922)
In the context of standards that could or should be changed to reform things, the traditional 'person of ordinary skill' standard need not be held as a constant.

For example, 'obviousness' could be more expansively construed as being from the perspective the kinds of people "skilled enough they are professionally tasked with inventing new approaches".

The relative preponderance of teams finding a particular solution, versus trying and failing, does seem relevant. (If 2-out-of-2-teams succeed, maybe they are geniuses, but the 100% success rate cannot disprove the hypothesis that the solution is obvious. If only 2-out-of-30 succeed, maybe there's rewardable inventiveness there.)

Still, when there are 2 or more cases of independent invention, that should be economically/legally relevant. This is especially true if one of the inventors didn't pursue a patent. While not be proof of traditional 'obviousness', it is evidence that the invention was "evident enough to be discovered as needed without patent incentives"... which sounds to me like the economically-ideal standard.

(And wouldn't that be a nice counterbalance to the 'patent everything defensively' scramble? That is: by inventing and using something without patenting it, not only would you have an absolute immunity from infringement, but also establish a presumption that specific practice was never deserving of patent protection in the first place.)

Re:Reforming the Patent System Toward a Minimalist System by rayiner on Monday October 01, 2012 @04:23AM (#4595841)
It's possible, but I think in a civil case where the burden of proof is "more (or less) likely than not" I think concurrent invention should create a strong presumption of obviousness.