Re:Reforming the Patent System Toward a Minimalist System
by rayiner on Monday October 01, 2012 @02:04AM
(#4595555)
Think of this in more precise economic terms. Say it takes $X to develop an invention that produces $Y of social benefit. If the invention is cheaply and easily copyable, people won't invest the $X unless they can recoup at least $X + some profit out of the $Y of social benefit. It's a classic free-rider problem. It's the economic reason why we have government-funded defense instead of private defense.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Reforming the Patent System Toward a Minimalist System
by jaekwon on Wednesday October 03, 2012 @03:10AM
(#4606229)
You're assuming that there exists some finite $X to develop some invention, as if you simply pour enough money into a problem, a solution will be found.
This is faulty logic. There is no direct correlation between money spent to develop, and outcome of desired invention/solution. Name one disease that needs to be treated/cured, and how much more money needs to be spent on R&D to find the solution. Nobody can do that. Ergo, your math does not apply.
When you let free-riding happen, (e.g. ban patents and allow copying of inventions, not to be confused with copying of brand), you let grass-roots innovation happen. More people get to understand the problem domain, more cheaply than any monopoly can manage.