News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Heartbeats in Distributed Systems by hinkley on Thursday November 13, 2025 @01:19PM (#45918463)
When systems were smaller I tried to push for the realization that I don’t need a heartbeat from a machine that is currently returning status 200 messages from 60 req/s. The evidence of work is already there, and more meaningful than the status check.

We end up adding real work to the status checks often enough anyway, to make sure the database is still visible and other services. So inference has a lot of power that a heartbeat does not.

Re:Heartbeats in Distributed Systems by taeric on Thursday November 13, 2025 @04:37PM (#45920930)
I'm amused that you got pushback. Just going on the metaphor, the very way that we check heartbeats in people is by a proof of work in some other part of the body. Isn't like we are directly hooked into the heart. It isn't like the heart sends out an otherwise useless signal.