News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by treetalker on Thursday November 13, 2025 @12:02PM (#45917319)
My pet view is that the fundamental flaw in the Constitution is its decreasing ability to enable coordinated change as population grows and more states enter the Union. Thus, change becomes progressively more difficult over time, whereas changes are increasingly necessary as time passes.

Yes, one of its main goals was to make change difficult. But political-party and legislator capture of the system has taken hold (easy example: representatives now pick their voters) and coordinating amendments we need is nigh impossible.

Periodic constitutional conventions would have helped.

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by potato3732842 on Thursday November 13, 2025 @12:12PM (#45917473)
This wasn't "suposed" to be an issue because the federal government was only really supposed to meddle in things that were obviously common issues or flagrantly interstate.

But now that it's in the business of taking everyone's money via income tax and then dolling it back out to the state to spend with strings attached (which is basically how the bulk of the non-entitlements, non-military money gets spent) the minutia of federal regulation matters far more.

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by redserk on Thursday November 13, 2025 @12:08PM (#45917407)
I can’t imagine the framers of the Constitution envisioned having 50 states, either.

26 Senators is a substantially different shape of legislative body than the current 100.

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by petcat on Thursday November 13, 2025 @12:25PM (#45917670)
There were already 25 states (50 Senators) by the time James Madison died in 1836. The original Constitution framers had already seen the explosive growth of the US during their lifetimes. So I can't imagine they didn't envision it.
Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by cthalupa on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:03PM (#45919801)
They might have envisioned it during their lifetimes, but I don't see how you can argue that things that happened after the Constitution/BoR were written informed their decisions while writing it.
Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by petcat on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:20PM (#45920001)
So maybe we're saying that the Founding Fathers were, in fact, not visionaries. Maybe they only had the same myopic 10-20 year view that anyone else today does.
Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by cthalupa on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:27PM (#45920072)
I think there is very little our founding fathers would recognize about today's american government, in a wide variety of ways.

Jefferson was probably the least myopic among them, in at least recognizing that all humans are myopic and struggle to have any concept of what the future holds.

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by theoldgreybeard on Thursday November 13, 2025 @02:59PM (#45919749)
The problem is too much centralization of power in the federal government, when the entire purpose of the constitution was supposed to be to LIMIT the power of the federal government so that states could mostly govern themselves.

California should make it's own laws, Montana should make it's own laws - and the federal government should set out the rules on how they talk to each-other.

States Rights are supposed to be the protection against political-party and legislator capture at the federal level.