Re:What happened to Transmeta, the last big dotcom IPO
by jasonwatkinspdx on Wednesday November 12, 2025 @06:56PM
(#45908640)
> At the point that Google's "bunch of cheap computers" was new
It wasn't even new, people just don't know the history. Inktomi and HotBot were based on a fleet of commodity PC servers with low reliability, whereas other large web properties of the time were buying big iron like Sun E10K. And of course Beowulf clusters were a thing.
And as far as I know, google's early ethos didn't come as some far sighted strategy, but just the practical reality of Page and Brin building the first versions of their search engine on borrowed/scavenged hardware as grad students and then continuing that trajectory.
Re:What happened to Transmeta, the last big dotcom IPO
by onecommentman on Wednesday November 12, 2025 @07:58PM
(#45909114)
The “bunch of cheap computers” approach was being studied and implemented at the National Labs years before Google showed up. Revisionist history?
Re:What happened to Transmeta, the last big dotcom IPO
by jasonwatkinspdx on Wednesday November 12, 2025 @08:16PM
(#45909233)
Not revisionist I think just more that a lot of people first encountered the concept with the story of Google and don't know it had plenty of precedent.
Except "the cloud" at that point was specifically just a large number of normal desktop-architecture machines. Specifically not a new ISA or machine type, running entirely normal OS and libraries. At no point did Google or Amazon or Microsoft make people port/rewrite all of their software for cloud deployment.
At the point that Google's "bunch of cheap computers" was new, CPU performance was still rapidly improving. The competition was traditional "big iron" or mainframe systems, and the novelty was in achieving high reliability through distribution, rather than building on fault-tolerant hardware. By the time the rate of CPU performance improvement was slowing in the mid 2000s, large clusters smaller machines were omnipresent in supercomputing and HPC applications.
The real "new architecture(s)" of this century are GPUs, but much of the development and success of them is the result of many iterations and a lot of convergent evolution.