News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Patent US6368227 - Method of swinging on a swing by ChuckMcM on Friday September 28, 2012 @01:18PM (#4586634)
I cannot help but think this patent and others like it would be good test cases for a summary reversal mechanism. I would use them as follows:

1) Create a policy whereby a patent can be identified as being 'issued in error' (to be clear the case is made that at the time of filing the patent basis was already unpatentable)

2) Provide a framework for describing the unpatentability and the evidence standards for elements in the framework (so you have to show it was obvious for example and have other indpendent inventions at a similar time, or prior art, etc)

3) Establish what rights the patent holder has in defending against this allocation (what rules of evidence are needed, what standard does that evidence need to meet)

4) Establish an appeal process, if any, and its rules.

5) Establish a way of introducing these disallowed patents as evidence of unpatentability in current office actions.

Then start with patents like this one and run them through that process.

Part of the problem here is that the challenge process is really broken and it needs to be fixed in order to balance out the inevitable human failings on the approval process.

There are no comments on this comment yet.