Then I'm going to read VCs investing in lots of companies as losers planning on losing.
VCs hedge their bets, almost by definition. What's wrong with founders doing the same?
I'm not really in favor of this particular proposal, but the idea of one-standard-for-you-another-for-me is a major turnoff.
It's a terrible argument, however, for convincing a VC to fund you.
All else being equal, it seems to me that a founder with a smart approach to managing risk is a better bet than one who is reckless about it.
It's not. What I was trying to say (perhaps unclearly) is it seems like you're arguing a moral point, that since VCs can diversify to reduce their risk, it's only fair that founders get to do the same.
And that's true. If you're founding a startup, and want to pool equity with other startups, nobody is going to prevent you. But VCs might be less inclined to fund you too.
So it's a question of what matters more to you -- taking more risk and perhaps getting more funding, or having less of both.
In fact, I wrote a blog post that's very relevant to this point:
http://diegobasch.com/traditional-vcs-and-first-time-entrepr...
Agreed. I just wrote an essay about this underlying issue of founder risk management [1], in response to PG's recent essay, and along the way I had this exact idea (swapping equity with other startups), and abandoned it because it seemed too complicated, as well as the adverse selection problem.
If it were to work, a major key would be the OP's first bullet point (in the "Gotchas" section of the original proposal) -- implementing a voting system, to ensure the startups in the pool are high quality.
But, like you said, no one wants to admit that they might fail.
"Advisors" to other companies also have this incentive, but that incentive is a pittance.
From a practical perspective, one largely buys insurance to smooth out either cash shocks or future decreases in earning potential rather than for diversification. Having a startup fail is not going to be a cash shock. Your earning potential if your startup fails should go up, because you're worth six figures on the open market trivially, and you probably were not paying yourself that previously.