News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:"I may have found a way to spot U.S. at-sea strikes befor... by nickff on Thursday November 06, 2025 @01:03AM (#45831974)
Could you please clarify this statement for me:

>”You can't shoot people in war because they are guilty of a crime unless they can legitamently be targeted for some other reason.”

From what I understand (and I am no expert), in a war, the default is that you can shoot someone if you believe them to be acting in a manner which is against your side’s interests (and have not surrendered while satisfying certain conditions).

Re:"I may have found a way to spot U.S. at-sea strikes befor... by bawolff on Thursday November 06, 2025 @06:21AM (#45833980)
You can shoot them if they are in combat against you, but that's not considered a crime and it would be illegal to arrest them for it. Soldiers are considered to have immunity for acts of war (except war crimes)

So for example it would be a war crime to punish someone for fighting in an opposing army. You can hold them as a prisoner of war for the duration of the conflict, but its supposed to be a means of keeping them out of a fight and not a punishment per se.

I think the biggest difference is that crimes can generally be punished after the fact. A murderer can be punished whenever they are caught. A soldier can be shot at at the time, but if they decide they are tired of the war and run away to a farm or something, they are now civilians and can no longer be shot at or punished for previously being a soldier (unless they comitted war crimes) even if the war is still raging on.

Re:"I may have found a way to spot U.S. at-sea strikes befor... by bawolff on Thursday November 06, 2025 @09:28AM (#45835625)
> Soldiers are considered to have immunity for acts of war (except war crimes)

Late edit: to clarify that is soldiers of an actual country have immunity. Combatants of a non-state group do not have immunity, so can be subject to arrest for merely participating in the conflict.