Re:Longtime Mozilla Support Japanese Community Shuts Down ov...
by thwarted on Wednesday November 05, 2025 @10:30PM
(#45831056)
What is the logic behind adding machine translation for content that already had a seemingly robust, enthusiastic, and motivated (volunteer?) community maintaining the translations? The "saves money" rationale to deploy LLM/MT automation doesn't make sense when its volunteers are contributing because they want to. This is kind of community and participation destruction wrought by the introduction of LLMs/MT has a serious impact because it undermines the people who are actually willing to do the work. It was presumably costing nothing (or very little) to have the community maintain this content, but the change has cost a significant amount of goodwill. If the Japanese SUMO community wanted to use MT, it should be their sole decision, baring any issues with their stewardship in general. This is someone else saying "look, with this great new automation, you don't need to spend time anymore doing «thing you want to do»". Huh? How does that make any sense to force on anyone?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Longtime Mozilla Support Japanese Community Shuts Down ov...
by overfeed on Wednesday November 05, 2025 @11:08PM
(#45831321)
Mozilla has long suffered from FAANG-envy. If big tech is doing Social Network|Mobile OS|AI, then by golly, Mozilla reflexively has to spend Firefox money on a poorly executed, me-too copy that's discarded when the next fad comes around. The sad thing is the reasoning is usually sound, but the execution... Yeesh.
Re:Longtime Mozilla Support Japanese Community Shuts Down ov...
by Brian_K_White on Wednesday November 05, 2025 @10:50PM
(#45831205)
I bet it's nothing more than they prefer a machine they can just use and get no lip, rather than have to deal with humans they have to treat like humans and ask nicely and meet half way on countless issues and pretend to care about etc.
Re:Longtime Mozilla Support Japanese Community Shuts Down ov...
by crazygringo on Wednesday November 05, 2025 @10:52PM
(#45831223)
There's probably a bunch of untranslated or badly translated content worldwide, so this was rolled out to help with that, without realizing it would overwrite higher-quality translation.
It probably made a lot of sense in certain contexts, and certain side effects weren't predicted, or it just has bugs that need fixing.
Presumably nothing malicious or stupid. But just ironing out the kinks.
Re:Longtime Mozilla Support Japanese Community Shuts Down ov...
by overfeed on Thursday November 06, 2025 @11:40AM
(#45837139)
> But just ironing out the kinks.
"Ironing out the kinks" in production on live data is stupid.
Re:Longtime Mozilla Support Japanese Community Shuts Down ov...
by crazygringo on Thursday November 06, 2025 @12:02PM
(#45837391)
All your production code has been entirely bug-free?
Nothing has ever gone wrong in production in ways that were fine on dev?
You've never written code to improve one metric, only to discover it made another metric worse that nobody had considered?
How about a little humility for the ways in which we're all fallible and usually just trying to do our best?
Re:Longtime Mozilla Support Japanese Community Shuts Down ov...
by overfeed on Thursday November 06, 2025 @03:41PM
(#45840147)
My fallibility doesn't make stupid actions any less stupid. I've done stupid things myself, like ssh into prod to apply a "simple, one-liner hotfix" which ended up upgrading a minor annoyance into a partial outage.
Re:Longtime Mozilla Support Japanese Community Shuts Down ov...
by crazygringo on Friday November 07, 2025 @11:15AM
(#45847938)
I don't think there's a lot of value in labeling things as "stupid" unless they are somehow willfully or recklessly so, which is rarely the case. I really don't know what it gets you.
Re:Longtime Mozilla Support Japanese Community Shuts Down ov...
by overfeed on Friday November 07, 2025 @11:37AM
(#45848182)
Even though you introduced the word/label to the thread, you may replace it with "unwise" or "ill-considered" if you find "stupid" too flippant.
Re:Longtime Mozilla Support Japanese Community Shuts Down ov...
by ForgetItJake on Thursday November 06, 2025 @12:05AM
(#45831696)
Mozilla is desperately trying to LARP as a tech giant.
Re:Longtime Mozilla Support Japanese Community Shuts Down ov...
by stonogo on Wednesday November 05, 2025 @10:49PM
(#45831199)
Mozilla has invested heavily in this technology, and whatever project manager is running it needs more checkboxes in the results column of their next request for a raise. In other words, "business alignment."
Re:Longtime Mozilla Support Japanese Community Shuts Down ov...
by o11c on Thursday November 06, 2025 @12:04AM
(#45831683)
In particular, "the content is useful" is not a checkbox. "The content is produced by this technology" is, and overwriting hand-curated content is an obvious action.
Re:Longtime Mozilla Support Japanese Community Shuts Down ov...
by dheatov on Thursday November 06, 2025 @06:47AM
(#45834172)
Less competent PMs are shoving capital A and capital I everywhere in panic mode, getting even more anxious as every failure exposes and deplatforms them even more.
They couldve spent time to understand the problem domain and think more, if theyre not already busy fabricating a resume to sneak into The Actual Big Tech.