Why?
Very short answer is Karl Friston's free energy pricniple
> each new token selection aims to bring predicted sensory input (the next word) into alignment with the model’s expectations.
what does that mean? An llm generates the next word based on what best matches its training, with some level of randomisation. Then it does it all again. It's not a percepual process trying to infer a reality from sensor data or anything
This is sort of accurate, but not precise.
An LLM generates the next token by sampling from a probability distribution over possible tokens, where those probabilities are computed from patterns learned during training on large text datasets.
The difference in our explanations is that you are biasing towards LLMs being fancy database indexes, and I am emphasizing that LLMs build a model of what they are trained on and respond based on that model, which is more like how brains and cells work than you are recognizing. (though I admit my understanding of microbiology places me just barely past peak Mt Stupid [Dunning Kruger], I don't really understand how individual cells do this and can only hand-wavey explain it).
Both systems take input, pass it through a network of neurons, and produce output. Both systems are trying to minimize surprise in predictions. The differences are primarily in scale and complexity. Human brains have more types of neurons (units) and more types of connections (parameters). LLMs more closely mimic the prefrontal cortex, whereas e.g. the brainstem is a lot more different in terms of structure and cellular diversity.
You can make a subjective ontological choice to draw categorical boundaries between them, or you can plot them on a continuum of complexity and scale. Personally I think both framings are useful, and to exclude either is to exclude part of the truth.
My point is that if you draw a subjective categorical boundary around what you deem is consciousness and say that LLMs are outside of that, that is subjectively valid. You can also say that consciousness is a continuum, and individual cells, blades of grass, ants, mice, and people experience different types of consciousness on that continuum. If you take the continuum view, then what follows is a reasonable assumption that LLMs experience a very different kind of consciousness that takes in inputs at about the same rate as a small fish, models those inputs for a few seconds, and then produces outputs. What exactly that "feels" like is as foreign to me as it would be to you. I assume its even more foreign than what it would "feel" like to be a blade of grass.
The free energy thing as I understand it has internal state, makes predictions, evaluates against new input and adjusts it internal state to continuously learn to predict new input better. This might if you squint look similar to training a neural network, although the mechanisms are different, but it's very distinct from the inference step
LLMs do everything modelled in the free energy principle, they just don't do continuous learning. (They don't do perceptual inference after RL)
Your tone ("free energy thing" and "if you squint") comes off as dismissive and not intellectually honest. Here I thought you were actually curious, but I guess not?
Totally possible that we're talking past each other.
To put it another way: lots of things are conscious, but humans are definitely the most conscious beings on Earth.
If one is to quantify consciousness it would probably make sense to think of it as an area of awareness and cognizance across time.
Awareness scales with sensory scale and resolution (sensory receptors vs input token limits and token resolution). E.g. 128k tokens and tokens too coarse to count rs in strawberry.
Cognizance scales with internal representations of awareness (probably some relation to vector space resolution and granularity, though I suspect there is more to it than just vector space)
And the third component is time, how long the agent is conscious for.
So something like...
Time * awareness (receptors) * internal representations (cell diversity * # cells * connection diversity * # connections)
There is no way this equation is right but I suspect it's sort of directionally correct.
I'm deep in the subject but just riffing here, so take this with a lot of salt.
I am not sure if chimps can do the same.
It's why anyone who's ever taken care of a needy pet will inevitably reach the comparison that taking care of a pet is similar to taking care of a very young child; it's needy, it experiences emotions but it can't quite figure out on its own how to adapt to an environment besides what it grew up around/it's own instincts. They experience some sort of qualia (a lot of animals are pretty family-minded), but good luck teaching a monkey to read. The closest we've gotten is teaching them that if they press the right button, they get food, but they take basically their entire lifespan to understand a couple hundred words, while humans easily surpass that.
IIRC some of the smartest animals in the world are actually rats. They experience a qualia very close to humans to the point that psychology experiments are often easily observable in rats.
If I had to guess, the current leading LLMs consciousness is most comparable to a small fish, with a conscious lifespan of a few seconds to a few minutes. Instead of perceiving water, nutrient gradients, light, heat, etc. it's perceiving tokens. It's conscious, but it's consciousness is so foreign to us it doesn't seem like consciousness. In the same way to an amoeba is conscious or a blade of grass is conscious but very different kind than we experience. I suspect LLMs are a new type of consciousness that's probably more different from ours than most if not all known forms of life.
I suspect the biggest change that would bring LLM consciousness closer to us would be some for of continuous learning/model updating.
Until then, even with RAG, and other clever teghniques I consider these models as having this really foreign slices of consciousness where they "feel" tokens and "act" out tokens, and they have perception, but their perception of the tokens is nothing like ours.
If one looks closely at simple organisms with simple sensory organs and nervous systems its hard not to see some parallels. It's just that the shape of consciousness is extremely different than any life form. (perception bandwidth, ability to act, temporality, etc)
Karl friston free energy principle gives a really interesting perspective on this I think.