Re:Dietary supplements: Scary substances manufactured under ...
by ZoFreX on Thursday September 27, 2012 @08:48AM
(#4580389)
> I strongly oppose any legislative efforts to make it more difficult for me to obtain these substances.
The way I took the article was that, if some sane rules were applied and enforced, it would actually be easier for you to obtain them - because right now you could be knocking back selenium and rat urine for all you know.
Re:Dietary supplements: Scary substances manufactured under ...
by Zak on Thursday September 27, 2012 @09:50AM
(#4580654)
What I took from the article is that its author would like supplements with drug-like effects regulated as drugs. That generally means they'd need clinical trials demonstrating that they're safe and effective for treating a specific disease, with extra-strong requirements to be sold without a prescription. I don't want that.
In his conclusion, he advocates milder measures for enforcement of purity and policing dubious advertising claims, but his use of "at least" implies he wants more rules.
That said, some companies in the supplement industry have, without a doubt behaved badly. It seems to me that there are three issues to consider.
* Advertising - making false claims in product marketing is already illegal.
* Purity - making false claims about what's in a product or selling a contaminated product is already illegal.
* Safety - if a substance can cause dangerous effects, the packaging should say so.
The first two are already the law. If there are loopholes or unreasonable barriers to enforcement, they should be patched. This doesn't require any major changes in policy - just fine-tuning to make sure existing policy can be enforced.
The last one is a bit more problematic under current policy. It's my impression that dangerous supplements can be sold with no labeling even when the dangers are fairly well known. The FDA's only recourse is to remove them from the market if they're found dangerous. I think mandatory warnings on packaging when there's significant evidence a supplement may be dangerous, similar to the black-box warnings on prescription drugs would be a good middle ground.