News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dietary supplements: Scary substances manufactured under ... by Gormo on Thursday September 27, 2012 @05:09AM (#4579945)
> > This would effectively outlaw the sale dietary supplements

> Why would this be a bad thing?

Because people who wish to consume dietary supplements would only be able to obtain them via black markets which would likely expose them to more, not less, potential danger.

Re:Dietary supplements: Scary substances manufactured under ... by derleth on Thursday September 27, 2012 @05:22AM (#4579965)
But fewer people total would consume them, leading to less damage being done overall.
Re:Dietary supplements: Scary substances manufactured under ... by Gormo on Thursday September 27, 2012 @05:36AM (#4579992)
The 'damage' described in the article is the result of mis-labeled products being sold to unwary consumers, not of properly-informed consumers experiencing negative consequences of risk judgments that they've intentionally chosen to make. This kind of damage is more likely to occur in a black market setting, in which the protections of law are unavailable, than it is to occur in an open and above-board market, in which participants have recourse against such fraud.

Consider also that suppressing supplements entirely also equally suppresses the benefit that consumers may enjoy from their use, and it's entirely plausible that the 'overall' reduction in benefit may exceed the 'overall' reduction in harm, so even if we were to use your purely utilitarian criterion as our only decision-making guide, such a policy might still be unjustified.

Re:Dietary supplements: Scary substances manufactured under ... by derleth on Thursday September 27, 2012 @06:09AM (#4580060)
> This kind of damage is more likely to occur in a black market setting

But less of it, since making it illegal would greatly reduce demand. Unless you can come up with a reason why supplements are similar enough to illegal drugs it wouldn't.

> Consider also that suppressing supplements entirely also equally suppresses the benefit that consumers may enjoy from their use

Empirically, that is a very minor concern, if it is one at all.

Re:Dietary supplements: Scary substances manufactured under ... by Gormo on Thursday September 27, 2012 @06:57PM (#4583355)
> But less of it, since making it illegal would greatly reduce demand

It would reduce the expression of demand, certainly, but not the actual desires of individuals that produced that expression; or to put it another way, will reduce the fulfillment of demand while the underlying unfulfilled demand still exists. This yields a net reduction in total happiness, which is counter to your apparent utilitarian ethos.

> Empirically, that is a very minor concern, if it is one at all.

Empirically? What does assessment of subjective value have to do with empirical data, apart from recognizing that individuals' subjective value empirically exists and is the source of demand?

Apart from that, apart from your apparent utilitarianism - the criteria of which remain yet unsatisfied in this discussion - what's the moral basis your assertion that forcibly denying the extant happiness of many is justifiable in order to reduce the potential unhappiness of few, especially considering that the former is not strictly necessary in order to achieve the latter, and that forcing a single uniform policy indiscriminately upon all is merely a contrivance of convenience?

Re:Dietary supplements: Scary substances manufactured under ... by derleth on Thursday September 27, 2012 @08:10PM (#4583616)
My moral basis is preventing fraud and punishing people who commit fraud.

> forcing a single uniform policy indiscriminately upon all is merely a contrivance of convenience

No. If you want to claim to promote health, your products need to be shown to promote health. Supplement makers have been able to get around that very basic moral law using loopholes and bought-off politicians. I want an end to that.

Re:Dietary supplements: Scary substances manufactured under ... by Gormo on Thursday September 27, 2012 @09:05PM (#4583801)
> My moral basis is preventing fraud and punishing people who commit fraud.

You appear to be going far beyond dealing with fraud, and instead wish to suppress activity that's being undertaken without any deceit.

> If you want to claim to promote health, your products need to be shown to promote health.

That's fine. Note, of course, that the vast majority of supplement products contain explicit disclaimers on their labels (e.g. "These statements have not been evaluated by the FDA" and "This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease") that make allegations of actual fraud quite spurious. And, of course, actual fraud of the kind described in the article - e.g. selling a bottle labeled "Vitamin C" that contains no actual vitamin C - is entirely illegal with or without FDA intervention.

However, if I want to purchase a bottle of foo, honestly labeled as "foo" without making any unsustainable promises, and use the contents of that bottle based upon my own understanding of the properties of "foo", that's entirely my prerogative, and it's entirely my right to assume whatever risks the use of foo entails.

(Of course, there is the issue of defining exactly what it actually means to "promote health".)

Re:Dietary supplements: Scary substances manufactured under ... by derleth on Thursday September 27, 2012 @10:23PM (#4584014)
> You appear to be going far beyond dealing with fraud, and instead wish to suppress activity that's being undertaken without any deceit.

'Deceit' does not start and end with the technical definition of fraud.

> Note, of course, that the vast majority of supplement products contain explicit disclaimers on their labels

They shout their ads and whisper their disclaimers. Why should we ignore their shouting?

> However, if I want to purchase a bottle of foo, honestly labeled as "foo" without making any unsustainable promises, and use the contents of that bottle based upon my own understanding of the properties of "foo", that's entirely my prerogative, and it's entirely my right to assume whatever risks the use of foo entails.

Why should you be able to sell something that you lead others to believe is good for them when it isn't?

Selling dandelions by marketing them as pretty flowers is fine. Selling them by marketing them as wine making material is also fine, as you can, in fact, make wine out of dandelions. Selling them by claiming dandelion wine is good for what ails you is lying. Can you honestly not see that last step?

Re:Dietary supplements: Scary substances manufactured under ... by Gormo on Friday September 28, 2012 @10:16AM (#4585605)
> 'Deceit' does not start and end with the technical definition of fraud.

No, but fraud does start and end within the definition of 'deceit'.

> They shout their ads and whisper their disclaimers. Why should we ignore their shouting?

I've not personally seen ads for supplements of the kind you're describing, but if they* were* advertising features that weren't actually available in the products, that is, at minimum, a bait-and-switch ad, which is already a fraudulent practice.

> Why should you be able to sell something that you lead others to believe is good for them when it isn't?

Whether it is or isn't "good for them" is, of course, determined by them - we're in the realm of value judgments here - and while it's entirely unethical and already illegal to sell someone a product on the basis of fraudulent information, selling a product with an explicit disclaimer that states that the product has not been empirically proven to fulfill any health claims made about it is perfectly legitimate.

Selling dandelions in a box marked "dandelions" without making any unprovable claims is always perfectly OK; selling dandelions as a cure for cancer is already a fraudulent activity punishable by law.

Re:Dietary supplements: Scary substances manufactured under ... by chmodd on Thursday September 27, 2012 @05:26AM (#4579975)
Re:Dietary supplements: Scary substances manufactured under ... by derleth on Thursday September 27, 2012 @06:07AM (#4580057)
There was and is a major cultural demand for alcohol that just isn't there for supplements.
Re:Dietary supplements: Scary substances manufactured under ... by Gormo on Thursday September 27, 2012 @06:59PM (#4583359)
This is apparently not the case, since a large number of people continue to purchase and consume supplements, and if the article is to be believed, this has resulted in providing the producers of those supplements with sufficient resources to successfully prevent their market from being suppressed by political activity, a feat which even the alcohol industry was unable to accomplish in 1919.