Are people on HN now not even able to think themselves out of a wet paper bag or something? You think that Spain and the UK sent their best, smartest, most sane, not at an all religiously zealous to the Americas and Australia? So yo think that Africa and Asia and Central/Southern America are sending their best, brightest, smartest, most sane, not at all criminal to the USA/Europe, even though that would solve so many of their problems?
Are people here children or something? Hell, I WOULD SEND ALL MY WORST if I were leading the "third world", because it is the only rational and sane thing to do; you improve your situation in one thousand dimensions, and degrade the "west" in that many and more. Who would not do that?
You look around the USA and Europe and you think to yourself that everything is working out really well, that immigration and the eradication and corruption of the indigenous cultures and people that produced everything we have will result in positive outcomes? How could you? No, I am seriously asking, I don't understand how the equivalent of, e.g., sabotaging or subverting the company you work for, that pays you and has done nothing but treat you well, will result in positive things for you or anyone. Now scale that up to all of Europe, the USA, and Australia. I guess China is assumed to be the natural heir to everything that Europe produced over thousands of years, but is effectively foreign to them too?
Like I said, hate Europe and the USA all you want, but I don't see the value, let alone sanity of cutting off your limbs to spite your face; and that's what is happening even though clearly the brakes are being pumped hard right now, as we are still speeding towards the abyss at far too great a speed. America is already minority made up of the people who made the Constitution and freedom possible, built the country and all it produced. Do we just scrap the Constitution because the creators do not embody the "diversity" of the people for whom the Constitution was not created? What happens then? We just end free speech? Ban the ability to defend against state power? No defense against warrantless surveillance and seizure? It's already bad enough with the treasonous assaults on the Constitution, what happens when the pretense is abandoned and the glass is shattered? You don't like being free? A creation of those horrible no good European men that create the Constitution?
But it does not matter if you think I am wrong or even a terrible, horrible, no good, very bad person of saying things that are not your favorite things to hear; reality is not going to care what you nor I think or wish.
In many ways, we are actually going through something very similar right now, Spain then, the UK a bit later, just like The “third world” today all expelled, sent, and removed by ultimatum trouble makers, criminals, problem children, zealots, etc and sent them to “the new world”, Australia/America, and Europe/USA; respectively. Currently we are living through the destruction of the “western” civilization all across the globe; and in my view, it will be the single most consequential event for all of humanity since the beginning of time, including the Bronze Age collapse and the crumbling of the Roman Empire. Yes, the total eradication of the whole civilization on the Americas by the Hispanics was also awful, but due to the relative isolation, it was less consequential. When the European global civilization that has brought humanity basically everything we currently have and take for granted crosses a negative feedback loop threshold, it will be extremely bad for all people of the world.
Humanity, what people consider that as today, is quite literally totally created and totally dependent on European peoples and cultures; the same people and cultures currently being eradicated and destroyed. That does not lead to positive outcomes, no matter if you absolutely hate Europeans or not.