This article has nothing to do with "grading" Apple maps.
But, OK, everyone! Turn off your brains! It's a Gruber article; all we're going to talk about is Gruber!
Re:Get the Fainting Chair
by ZeroGravitas on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @03:15PM
(#4577447)
No, but if it had been a competitors product it would have been graded, and harshly. But instead it's an Apple product that's clearly a bit rubbish so we get some meandering drivel about how they were forced to do this for the greater good and Google is smart and evil but also incompetent and ignorant, and Apple is noble, pure and selfless for foisting half-baked maps on its users. Because a phone constantly reporting your position back to Apple so it can build maps and sell phones is so much less creepy than doing so to help Google build maps and sell ads.
The point you're making has nothing to do with the article. The article isn't "meandering drivel"; it's a summary of actual reporting on what led Apple to make the decision it did.
Re:Get the Fainting Chair
by ZeroGravitas on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @03:20PM
(#4577474)
Oh come on, who's turned off their brain now? His job is writing apologia for Apple. Apple messed up. It's his job to spin it to suit his readership's preconcieved ideas (and then sell ads to them).
"I don’t understand why so many reviewers bend over backwards to grade these things on a curve. If Google or Nokia Maps had the problems and deficiencies the Apple Maps have, these same reviewers would (rightly) trash it, and declare (again, rightly) that Google had finally lost its touch.
These aren’t “beta” maps. They’re bad maps. It’s that simple. It’s true that their presentation seems closer to Google-caliber than their data, but improving the data is the hardest part of making maps like these. By the time Apple releases “a serious update or three” the entire market will have changed. The truth is, Apple has released a would-be Google Maps competitor that pales compared to Google Maps. Just say it.
The mass market doesn’t buy, and doesn’t want to buy, products based on what they might become months from now if these companies somehow dramatically improve the software. They buy products for what they are today, out of the box. Google and Nokia are Apple’s industry peers. These are the big leagues, this is The Show. They’re charging customers real money to buy these things. They should be judged by the same standards."
Of course, he wasn't actually talking about Apple maps then so he didn't try quite so hard to see it from their point of view.
http://daringfireball.net/linked/2011/04/21/mccracken-beta-h...