Re:Actual OIS performance: Lumia 920 against iPhone 5, Galax...
by potatolicious on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @10:53AM
(#4575931)
sigh So the OIS actually does work as well as claimed, which boggles the mind why they felt they had to fake it in the ad.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Actual OIS performance: Lumia 920 against iPhone 5, Galax...
by sp332 on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @10:56AM
(#4575941)
It probably wasn't ready to run on an actual phone at the time.
Re:Actual OIS performance: Lumia 920 against iPhone 5, Galax...
by wvenable on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @12:00PM
(#4576313)
Unless you're comparing it directly with another phone, it's hard to imagine any phone image stabilization looking good in a commercial.
Re:Actual OIS performance: Lumia 920 against iPhone 5, Galax...
by rhinoid on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @12:11PM
(#4576376)
Because the phone is not ready yet.
btw it's a test controlled by Nokia. I think we should wait until it's finally released before giving the final judgement.
Re:Actual OIS performance: Lumia 920 against iPhone 5, Galax...
by randallu on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @12:11PM
(#4576377)
So maybe The Verge's whole freakout over it was completely unwarranted? Maybe Nokia knew what the effect of OIS would be when they made the ad -- after having done the R&D to develop the camera in the first place?
Re:Actual OIS performance: Lumia 920 against iPhone 5, Galax...
by objclxt on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @01:39PM
(#4576887)
I disagree: I think it was somewhat warranted. The fact the end-result looks similar to the faked result is beside the point.
Many countries, the US included, have decided that if you cannot fake product demos in advertising unless it is clear that's what's going on. Hence the "Sequences Shortened" text on the iPhone ads.
It is rather unethical to produce a marketing video that fakes functionality and doesn't make it clear that's what's going on. You may well not be over-exaggerating anything, but personally I don't think that's relevant.
Re:Actual OIS performance: Lumia 920 against iPhone 5, Galax...
by untog on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @02:52PM
(#4577318)
I would argue that the "Sequences Shorted" text doesn't make anything clear at all. It's a barely noticeable cop-out.
Re:Actual OIS performance: Lumia 920 against iPhone 5, Galax...
by JimmaDaRustla on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @11:55AM
(#4576282)
Why would one express sorrow for a huge innovation in technology?
Re:Actual OIS performance: Lumia 920 against iPhone 5, Galax...
by barista on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @02:51PM
(#4577314)
I doubt I'd call it faked. Would you call siri ads faked? Everybody who has used it can vouch that it just doesn't work let alone in noisy downtown.
It was a promo video used when revealing a product (not an ad broadcast on TV) that was trying to prove a point that OIS is important and can make pictures and videos look beautiful. The verge and all other sites that did the detective work was purely for the sake of page views. No substance there...