* It doesn’t have ongoing powers, authority, or political discretion like a parliament or the European Council.
* It’s a one-time, ceremonial body that meets once every four years to cast votes reflecting (in nearly all cases) the popular vote results in each state.
2. Electors don’t deliberate or choose freely.
* In almost every state, electors are legally bound (or at least politically bound) to vote according to their state’s popular vote.
* So the outcome is functionally determined by voters, not by an independent decision of the Electoral College.
3. The EU analogy misrepresents the role of the Electoral College.
* In the EU, citizens elect national governments, which then appoint members of the European Council, who negotiate and nominate the EU Commission — a genuine appointment process.
* In the U.S., the electors are not government officials making appointments; they are agents executing the people’s will as expressed in the election.
---
In the US, the people elect the President, because electors vote as their state’s voters directed.
The EU Commission analogy doesn’t fit, because that’s an appointment process made by governments, not a formalization of a direct vote.
Fact of the matter is, neither the US President nor the EU Commission are directly elected. Both are appointed with one layer of indirection between them and a direct vote.
Either we call both elected or we call both unelected. To do so for one, but not the other is anti-European propaganda.
The same way that voters elect their national governments, which then appoint the Commission.