It is more nuanced, for example Medicare Advantage(Part C) is paid by Medicare money but it is profitable private operators who provide the plans and service it a fast growing part of Medicare .
John Oliver had an excellent segment coincidentally yesterday on this topic.
While the government pays for it, it is not managed or run by them so how to classify the program as public or private ?
That's a great and thorough analysis!
My take away is that as public health costs are overtaking private insurance and at the same time doing a better job controlling costs per enrollee, it makes more and more sense just to have the government insure everyone.
I can't see what argument the private insurers have in their favor.
I disagree with the statement that healthcare insurance is predominantly privatized in the US: Medicare and Medicaid, at least in 2023, outspent private plans for healthcare spending by about ~10% [1]; this is before accounting for government subsidies for private plans. And boy, does America have a very unique relationship with these programs.
https://www.healthsystemtracker.org/chart-collection/u-s-spe...