Skeuomorphism is an easy target because it is dishonest by definition. Things that appear "cutting edge" or "high quality" today will, in a few years, seem dated, clunky, and pointless.
By contrast, pick up a copy of Die Neue Typography and see how well not just Tschichold's designs, but his ideas, hold up today. Skeuomorphism is a symbol of the Old UI. What we need is the New UI.
http://byamt.wordpress.com/2009/03/03/dieter-rams/
> By contrast, pick up a copy of Die Neue Typography and see how well not just Tschichold's designs, but his ideas, hold up today.
Dieter Ram's designs also hold up. Honesty is at the center of it all. This is also the reason why people still quote Confucius. Honesty is simply living and experiencing in the purest way possible.
I think your own example illustrates it: a film without special effects is just a film.
It's not about flat design being right or wrong, it's more about whether it's appropriate for the job/task and audience/market.
There are good movies with special effects and good movies without special effects -- it's just a one element of the entire experience and by no means the most important.