Re:Show HN: A place for stories
by user24 on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @04:09AM
(#4569203)
I think you need a mission statement/elevator-pitch style intro to the raison d'etre of the site. At the moment I'm having to invest time reading multiple snippets and inferring the overall goal of your project from them, which is difficult.
Re:Show HN: A place for stories
by storylike on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @04:54AM
(#4569334)
I agree that it might not be obvious what the site does when you see it the first time, I will put a up faq but i don't want to take room on the front page to explain the site, it doesn't seem right.
Re:Show HN: A place for stories
by storylike on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @04:25AM
(#4569250)
Yes, they are quotes from blogs and personal stories, some are short and the have whole story in the quote but most are longer and you have to go to the source to read it all.
Re:Show HN: A place for stories
by paigalhaes on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @10:06AM
(#4570372)
The share seems a bit odd, since I have to leave the site to read the story, and probably will share it from there (the original site).
Probably it should be visible below the quote, and not only sharing the title and link, but the quote itself (less for twitter 140 chars) because that's what I want to share from your site.
Re:Show HN: A place for stories
by binarysolo on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @04:07AM
(#4569201)
What determines that a story would get aggregated by the site? And what determines the passage selected? (Am curious if it's crowdsourced, curated, algo-driven, machine-learned, etc.)
Re:Show HN: A place for stories
by storylike on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @04:21AM
(#4569241)
Right now i select the quote myself. I read the post and try to find the best quote to serve as a introduction to the story.
I have rating system in place on a scale of 1-10 but i didn't give all the stories a rating yet. I want to crowdsource the ratings in the future, it's on the list of things to add.
Re:Show HN: A place for stories
by binarysolo on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @05:59PM
(#4572912)
Grats on the simplicity of the site and repository of good stories. I think as a portfolio piece it's very serviceable.
As for growing the site itself, I think you'd need to somehow provide some unique-ish value prop to differentiate yourself from yet-another-social-discovery/bookmarking-service, in more than a "StumbleUpon for HN articles" kinda way.
Re:Show HN: A place for stories
by denzil_correa on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @05:06AM
(#4569361)
Do you have to explicitly be submitted a story or your system is uber smart to crawl the interesting ones and generate the best? A system for the latter would be quite cool.
Probably it should be visible below the quote, and not only sharing the title and link, but the quote itself (less for twitter 140 chars) because that's what I want to share from your site.
You probably want to do some A/B testing on your choice of quote. I think that's legitimate.
I personally think the domain name of your site is a little simple. Just my opinion though and I know the domain name market is a nightmare.
I have rating system in place on a scale of 1-10 but i didn't give all the stories a rating yet. I want to crowdsource the ratings in the future, it's on the list of things to add.
As for growing the site itself, I think you'd need to somehow provide some unique-ish value prop to differentiate yourself from yet-another-social-discovery/bookmarking-service, in more than a "StumbleUpon for HN articles" kinda way.
Good luck!