News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Liberal Arts Colleges Are Failing America by gruseom on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @03:07AM (#4569048)
The value of education, traditionally, is that it makes you a civilized human being. There are many ways for that to benefit society.

It's only our narrow age, that conflates education with training and value with economic utility, that would think of GDP as the only contribution.

Re:How Liberal Arts Colleges Are Failing America by _dps on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @06:02AM (#4569533)
I agree with one minor quibble: I don't think it's a conflation of education with economic utility, but rather a convergence. To put it another way, it's not so much a new perception of education but rather a new reality colliding with a 50-year old perception.

Modern employment markets are simply more efficient in pricing the various components of human capital than they used to be; it used to be enough to be smart and good at anything challenging at all (the classical liberal arts value proposition is, I submit, fundamentally based on this idea). The "learning to learn" and "critical thinking" components of this education were valuable enough to demand a price premium relative to 1950s vocational education, but it's much harder to compete with a modern degree in (say) mathematics which, I claim, is at least as powerful in developing said meta-skills as a degree in literature (and has the added bonus of having direct economic value in many industries). Over time, market forces will adjust the prices for these two different investments accordingly.

Thinking purely economically (obviously, there's more to life than economics), education in a subject for which no one will pay and which has no measurable positive externalities is indistinguishable (to the market) from consumption. So I think the future for these kinds of degrees will hinge heavily on finding evidence of positive externalities, or accepting that a degree in medieval history is better compared to a seminary (i.e. no expectation of economic reward) than a medical school.

Edit/Note: I realize that mathematics degrees, done in certain ways, can fit inside the framework of a liberal arts education. However, all the mathematicians of my generation I know took as many math courses as possible within the requirements of their degree programs. I speculate that, even at liberal arts schools, mathematicians pursue much more concentrated curricula than the typical student.

Re:How Liberal Arts Colleges Are Failing America by mjt0229 on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @09:27AM (#4570185)
I quibble with your quibble. This article does conflate economic return with actual value. Many people contribute positively to society (including economically), without necessarily being directly compensated proportionally to their contribution. For example, I am an engineer at a research institute that does a substantial amount of cancer and other medical research. As a CS guy, I get a pretty nice salary. However, there are plenty of folks who I work with whose degrees came from liberal arts education who contribute more directly to the cancer research, but whose salaries are lower than mine. Much of this research might actually go on to make pharmaceutical companies substantial profits, but these people will not be directly or proportionally compensated for that. If some of the research does not translate to therapeutics, then they will not have increased economic value at all, but will have definitely added intellectual and scientific value - a value that is not really easy to measure on a simple economic scale --- and certainly not on one so simple-minded as the one used in the article.
Re:How Liberal Arts Colleges Are Failing America by yummyfajitas on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @07:42AM (#4569789)
...a civilized human being. There are many ways for that to benefit society.

Could you define "civilized human being", and perhaps explain what some of those ways are?

I.e., explain it to me like I'm 5.

Re:How Liberal Arts Colleges Are Failing America by mjt0229 on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @09:20AM (#4570149)
Some of the best technical thinkers I've met came from a liberal arts background. The exposure to a broad range of ideas from a variety of fields including both the natural sciences, math, the social sciences, literature, etc., prepares a person to think about problems from a variety of perspectives, to think about the impacts of their decision making processes, etc. It's about mental flexibility, it's about being a cultured human being, it's about having a shared language and metaphors to enable one to better participate in society.
Re:How Liberal Arts Colleges Are Failing America by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @08:59AM (#4570074)
How about: Sharing core values, understading shared history, arguing from shared premises makes public discourse meaningful instead of anarchic.
Re:How Liberal Arts Colleges Are Failing America by yummyfajitas on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @09:16AM (#4570129)
Sharing core values...arguing from shared premises...

So the purpose of college is indoctrination? Good to know.

Re:How Liberal Arts Colleges Are Failing America by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @09:41AM (#4570255)
Right, but you use that word like its a bad thing? Don't you spend most of your time indoctrinating your kids? Don't hit your brother! Be polite to your mother! Don't shove! Shut up and sit down!

Doctrine, other than political, is critical to civilization.

Re:How Liberal Arts Colleges Are Failing America by locopati on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @10:44AM (#4570580)
Perhaps considering the ramifications of your actions beyond the narrow focus of personal interest, near-group interest, or economic interest.
Re:How Liberal Arts Colleges Are Failing America by yummyfajitas on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @11:21AM (#4570800)
If that is the case, you should probably consider religion rather than college.
Re:How Liberal Arts Colleges Are Failing America by locopati on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @01:57PM (#4571693)
Are you really saying that it's only by religion that people can consider their impact on others?
Re:How Liberal Arts Colleges Are Failing America by yummyfajitas on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @02:26PM (#4571851)
No, I'm saying religion seems more likely to do this than college. Cheaper too.