Re:Knocker, a knock based access control system for your hom...
by lucideer on Wednesday October 22, 2025 @08:11AM
(#45667858)
I'm on Merlin currently but I'm in the process of moving over to OPNSense for this exact reason.
However, while you can never really trust anything you run with internet access, I feel there's a fundamental line between an explicitly cloud-dependent service like Tailscale (e.g. a Tailscale control server outage incident would impact your home server access) compared to a fully self-hosted service that may or may not phone home if you don't put preventative measures in front of it, but will continue to function fine if you do put said measures in place.
The Asus mobile app is another potential concern but the Merlin browser UI is fine for most purposes.
Re:Knocker, a knock based access control system for your hom...
by aspenmayer on Wednesday October 22, 2025 @12:33PM
(#45671646)
> However, while you can never really trust anything you run with internet access, I feel there's a fundamental line between an explicitly cloud-dependent service like Tailscale (e.g. a Tailscale control server outage incident would impact your home server access) compared to a fully self-hosted service that may or may not phone home if you don't put preventative measures in front of it, but will continue to function fine if you do put said measures in place.
This is why I mentioned Headscale in the first place. It’s not for everyone or every use case, but it’s good that it exists, on the whole.
I would agree that stock WireGuard is going to have the fewest dependencies, and I don’t mean to nitpick or be disagreeable because I do agree with you, that fewer third party dependencies is usually better than more.
The Asus-Merlin firmware is also nice, though the stock Asus firmwares have gotten pretty good and work for most folks for many use cases. I think VLAN config and tagging support might be one of the only features I wanted that stock Asus firmware didn’t handle when I used them last.