Re:How Apple's Obsession with Google Is Hurting Apple
by saurik on Sunday September 23, 2012 @11:37PM
(#4563082)
We have good evidence for turn-by-turn, though: when Apple decided "ok, we cave, here's an SDK and an App Store", the contracts with developers had a weird clause saying you couldn't build a turn-by-turn application that was later changed to only that you could not build a turn-by-turn application using the data that Apple had licensed from Google; while this isn't for certain, the obvious interpretation of this is that when Apple built the iPhone they licensed Google Maps but with the clause "the iPhone cannot do turn-by-turn", which got awkward with an SDK, and later got fixed in legalese to specify "we cannot do it, but if someone else independently has data and licenses it, they can".
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:How Apple's Obsession with Google Is Hurting Apple
by fpgeek on Monday September 24, 2012 @12:00AM
(#4563145)
It is worth noting that Google themselves didn't offer turn-by-turn directions until Android 2.0 (October 2009). Interestingly, Google Maps Navigation launched in the US shortly after they had ditched Tele Atlas (owned by TomTom) as a US data provider. It was speculated (though not confirmed, as far as I could find) that Google ended the relationship because it was too expensive/restrictive with respect to turn-by-turn navigation.
That makes me wonder if original turn-by-turn restrictions were Google's idea or a requirement of Google's existing contracts. If so, it's obvious Google decided to continue those restrictions for their own reasons and so history has repeated itself.
Re:How Apple's Obsession with Google Is Hurting Apple
by DrStalker on Monday September 24, 2012 @01:14AM
(#4563315)
Given how much TomTom charged for their navigation app long after GPS stopped being a high cost luxury product I wouldn't be surprised if they demanded too much money from Google.
Re:How Apple's Obsession with Google Is Hurting Apple
by adnrw on Sunday September 23, 2012 @11:54PM
(#4563123)
...the obvious interpretation of this is that when Apple built the iPhone they licensed Google Maps but with the clause "the iPhone cannot do turn-by-turn"
This is from Google's Maps/Earth API TOS:
10.2 (c) No Navigation, Autonomous Vehicle Control, or Enterprise Applications:
(i) real time navigation or route guidance, including but not limited to turn-by-turn route guidance that is synchronized to the position of a user's sensor-enabled device.
- https://developers.google.com/maps/terms
As far as I know, that clause has always been in the TOS (I looked into the licensing in 2010 and it definitely was in there then).
Re:How Apple's Obsession with Google Is Hurting Apple
by SoftwareMaven on Monday September 24, 2012 @12:11AM
(#4563178)
While true for the average developer, I would imagine a deal brokered between bizdev teams would look drastically different than those ToS.
Re:How Apple's Obsession with Google Is Hurting Apple
by clutteredname_ on Monday September 24, 2012 @12:56AM
(#4563275)
A valid point, but it is conceivable that a similar clause would find its way into larger licensing/development agreements. Turn-by-turn could have been some gem thy wanted to hold as Google's one-up on any client built using their own API. Truthfully, it would be dumb of Google to give away everything, and keeping turn-by-turn (or even just a broader navigation scope) is something I can see as the ace in the hole they hold onto regardless.