News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why the push for Agentic when models can barely follow a ... by wongarsu on Tuesday October 14, 2025 @04:38AM (#45577640)
I have had LLMs write entire codebases for me, so it's not like the hype is completely wrong. It's just that this only works if what you want is "boring", limited in scope and on a well-trodden path. You can have an LLM create a CRUD application in one go, or if you want to sort training data for image recognition you can have it generte a one-off image viewer with shortcuts tailored to your needs for this task. Those are powerful things and worthy of some hype. For anything more complex you very quickly run into limits and the time and effort to do it with an LLM quickly approaches the time and effort required to do it by hand.
Re:Why the push for Agentic when models can barely follow a ... by physicsguy on Tuesday October 14, 2025 @05:23AM (#45577912)
They're powerful, but my feeling is that largely you could do this pre-LLM by searching on Stack Overflow or copying and pasting from the browser and adapting those examples, if you knew what you were looking for. Where it adds power is adapting it to your particular use case + putting it in the IDE. It's a big leap but not as enormous a leap as some people are making out.

Of course, if you don't know what you are looking for, it can make that process much easier. I think this is why people at the junior end find it is making them (a claimed) 10x more productive. But people who have been around for a long time are more skeptical.

Re:Why the push for Agentic when models can barely follow a ... by disgruntledphd2 on Tuesday October 14, 2025 @06:24AM (#45578286)
> Where it adds power is adapting it to your particular use case + putting it in the IDE. It's a big leap but not as enormous a leap as some people are making out.

To be fair, this is super, super helpful.

I do find LLMs helpful for search and providing a bunch of different approaches for a new problem/area though. Like, nothing that couldn't be done before but a definite time saver.

Finally, they are pretty good at debugging, they've helped me think through a bunch of problems (this is mostly an extension of my point above).

Hilariously enough, they are really poor at building MCP like stuff, as this is too new for them to have many examples in the training data. Makes total sense, but still endlessly amusing to me.

Re:Why the push for Agentic when models can barely follow a ... by Izkata on Tuesday October 14, 2025 @08:42AM (#45579351)
Why bother searching yourself? This is pre-LLM: https://github.com/drathier/stack-overflow-import
Re:Why the push for Agentic when models can barely follow a ... by marcosdumay on Tuesday October 14, 2025 @11:40AM (#45581358)
> Of course, if you don't know what you are looking for, it can make that process much easier.

Yes. My experience is that LLMs are really, really good at understanding what you are trying to say and bringing up the relevant basic information. That's a task we call "search", but it is different from the focused search people do most of the time.

Anyway, by the nature of the problem, that's something that people should do only a few times for each subject. There is not a huge market opportunity there.

Re:Why the push for Agentic when models can barely follow a ... by alwahi on Tuesday October 14, 2025 @05:10AM (#45577840)
i have seen so many people say that, but the app stores/package managers aren't being flooded with thousands of vibe coded apps, meanwhile facebook is basically ai slop. can you share your github? or a gist of some of these "codebases"
[dead]
Re:Why the push for Agentic when models can barely follow a ... by kordlessagain on Tuesday October 14, 2025 @12:54PM (#45582281)
It’s hardly slop when you have over a 100 different sources referenced in a targeted paper.