Do you really prefer brutal serfdom to the AI supremacy scenario? From where I sit, people have mixed (trending positive) feelings about AI, and hard negative feelings about being in debt and living paycheck to paycheck. I'd like to understand your position here more.
What I found persuasive was the argument that this bubble could be worse than others due to the perceived geopolitical stakes by US leadership, plausibly leading to mass serfdom as our society implodes, based on the argument that we already have a version of serfdom today. I found that astute.
I do NOT think that scenario is favorable - it just seems like the most likely future. I hold that we should view our situation with clear eyes so that we can make the best decision from where we stand.
Thinking through this, what does that mean for how we should face our present moment? Eventually people will throw off their chains; our leadership is so incompetently invested in class war that the working class is going to continue to be squeezed and squeezed - until it pops. It’s a pattern familiar in history. The question in my mind is not if but when. And the sooner we get our collective act together the less painful it’s going to be. There’s some really bad stuff waiting for us round the bend.
What should we do? The economy depends on us the serfs and soon-to-be serfs. It’s the workers who can take control of it and can shut it down with mass strikes. It’s only this in my view that can plausibly free us from our reckless leadership (which goes beyond the current administration) and the bleak future they are preparing for us.
1. Fusion 2. Pharmaceuticals (think Ozempic economic benefit X 100) 3. Advanced weaponry (if warlike, don't build just conquer) 4. Advanced propaganda to destabilize other nations (again, if warlike)
This is mostly off the cuff, given the success of AlphaEvolve and AlphaFold I don't think they're unreasonable.
I think holding on to these beliefs about AI must give some people a sense of hope. But a hope based on reality and is stronger than one based in denial. The antidote is solidarity founded on our shared vulnerability before this bleak future.
The US indeed seems destined to fall behind due to decades of economic mismanagement under neoliberalism while China’s public investment has proved to be the wise choice. Yet this fact wounds the pride of many in the US, particularly its leaders, so it now lashes out in a way that hastens its decline.
The AI supremacy bet proposed is nuts. Prior to every societal transition the seeds of that transition were already present. We can see that already with AI: social media echo chambers, polarization, invading one’s own cities, oligarchy, mass surveillance.
So I think the author’s other proposed scenario is right - mass serfdom. The solution to that isn’t magical thinking but building mass solidarity. If you look at history and our present circumstances, our best bet to restore sanity to our society is mass strikes.
I think we are going to get there one way or another. Unfortunately things are probably going to have to get a lot more painful before enough people wake up to what we need to do.